Wheel of Time

sakkath · May 21, 2021

"Tuon, tough? True, she was the Daughter of the Nine Moons and all of that, and she had been able to get under his skin with a look back in the Tarasin Palace, when he thought she was just another Seachan noblewoman with her nose in the air, but that was just because she kept turning up where he did not expect. No more than that. Tough? She looked like a doll made of black porcelain. How tough could she be?"

From Crossroads of Twilight

Aldarion · May 21, 2021

what the fuck, how many hours did I spend reading those books and never once pictured Tuon as black.

Not clear how Artur Hawkwing's descendants ended up African but I guess I cant argue with text references.

So they were a race of black people who brought slavery to the Westlands?

Brahma · May 21, 2021

Aldarion said:
lol no. I see your fan fic picture but did you even read those books? I don't recall a single mention of the Seanchan being black. Werent they Artur Hawkwing's descendants, from the same land as the main characters?

Yes, a quick wiki review says they were. What is this fan fic Seanchan were black nonsense?

It does seem like there may have been one or two dark skinned forsaken, though.

“Tuon raised a peremptory hand, a black porcelain doll, but every inch a queen despite the shabby, too large dress” – Crossroads of Twilight

Tuon did have the surname Paendragon so you got that right.

OU Ariakas · May 21, 2021

To be honest, their names and culture of honor/deference made me always picture them as Asian even thought the description was that they were darker. I get that it is a fantasy realm, but the history of this world kept making me think Samurai-esque society. It would be like naming a character something undeniably European, having them live in gothic castles with flying buttresses and caste system, and then describing their appearance as Native American.

Brahma · May 21, 2021

OU Ariakas said:
To be honest, their names and culture of honor/deference made me always picture them as Asian even thought the description was that they were darker. I get that it is a fantasy realm, but the history of this world kept making me think Samurai-esque society. It would be like naming a character something undeniably European, having them live in gothic castles with flying buttresses and caste system, and then describing their appearance as Native American.

Dude seriously I thought of them as black folk with Asian armors flying on Manta Rays? Best way I can describe it. RJ was all over the place in his race regards. BUT he was very specific about the big three.

Furry · May 21, 2021

I always imagined them as black people, the Aiel as fremen from dune, and the rest of the cultures were more vague. I definitely thought of rand's area and the more north as whiter, and the southern parts as perhaps middle eastern or asian. These books were written before wokeness was a thing. For that I'm glad, I don't need to be beaten over the head with this world while trying to enjoy the idea of a different world.

Zindan · May 21, 2021

Not all Seanchan were as dark skinned as Tuon. The people that left Randland were a mix of all the people of Randland at the time of Hawkwing. The lands of Seanchan were just as multi-racial. There are probably several descriptions of the various Seanchan characters which would show them to be of various skin colors, but all unified into the dominant culture that is a mix of Hawkwing era and whatever was present in Seanchan.

Zindan · May 21, 2021

Furry said:
I'm gonna give it a chance. The setting allows for a lot of flexibility in terms of diversity, so I can at least turn a blind eye to that. Would it be too much to fucking ask if they looked at how good the actors are at acting before looking at their checklist, though?

We'll see which order they looked at things when this comes out.

Not at all, at least in regards to the main characters. That cast isn't diverse enough to stop the show runners from changing things (Perrin being black, etc.). So it will be a shitshow in regards to that. Now whether it is well written and acted...just have to wait and see.

Sterling · May 21, 2021

Sea Folk were dark. Some Seanchan are dark. Tairens I always thought were likely spanish/mediteranean types, aiel are desert people. They never really specify what sort of skin tone most others have but if The Two Rivers is some backwoods isolated area you'd think they'd largely be similar regardless of which choice they make. At least Semirhage is black among the Chosen. Seems like there's plenty of diversity just built in already.

Zindan · May 21, 2021

Brahma said:
This legit for real?

There are plenty of side characters they could have used for their diversity. The Aiel you could have easily made diverse since they were a desert people. Give Tuon and the Seanchan a more screen time if you need to.

The Aiel were/are as white as can be. Given how reclusive they were, a dramatic change to their "ethnicity" would be impossible, and could only come from sjw writers. Having a non white Aiel would be as silly as having a non black Tuon or Semirhage. Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I would prefer a tv adaptation of a book to be as close to what was written as possible, but no, now we have writers that just have to change things.

Brahma · May 21, 2021

Zindan said:
The Aiel were/are as white as can be. Given how reclusive they were, a dramatic change to their "ethnicity" would be impossible, and could only come from sjw writers. Having a non white Aiel would be as silly as having a non black Tuon or Semirhage. Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I would prefer a tv adaptation of a book to be as close to what was written as possible, but no, now we have writers that just have to change things.

My example was strictly on trying to sell it as a reasoning WHY they could be brown. Not that they should. Not sure how you have a bunch of black red heads running around

Brahma · May 21, 2021

Sterling said:
Seems like there's plenty of diversity just built in already.

Yeah. Not sure why they need to fuck with any of the main characters. Like I said. You want diversity in this series, just give more screen time to those you want to promote.

Furry · May 21, 2021

Brahma said:
Yeah. Not sure why they need to fuck with any of the main characters. Like I said. You want diversity in this series, just give more screen time to those you want to promote.

TBH I don't give a shit as long as he can act. Seeing that he's Perrin, all he has to do is act retarded and have big muscles and he'll play the role right. If he doesn't look like chef rush a few seasons in I'm gonna be disappoint.

Zindan · May 21, 2021

Brahma said:
Yeah. Not sure why they need to fuck with any of the main characters. Like I said. You want diversity in this series, just give more screen time to those you want to promote.

I doubt the series will get past Eye of the World, so not a large number of side characters to really focus on. Memory is a bit foggy, but the major areas we'll see are Edmonds Field, Taren Ferry, Whitebridge, Caemlyn, a bit of Tar Valon and then Fal Dara.

Falstaff · May 21, 2021

On the Q&A they had the other day, whoever was doing it (the Rand actor maybe?) said that it won't be 1 season = 1 book. Not sure if that's relevant for earlier seasons or whatever later seasons they have planned.

Lenardo · May 21, 2021

why we worried about tuon? if they follow the timeline...BOOK 9 is when Tuon first arrives from Seanchan.

she is mentioned in book 1 by the high lord ( as the daughter of the nine moons) but that is about the last time she is mentioned until she arrives in ebou dar.

granted her and matt's interactions are about my favorite relationship in the series...and the prophesy about matt and her is just awesome.

Furry · May 21, 2021

Falstaff said:
On the Q&A they had the other day, whoever was doing it (the Rand actor maybe?) said that it won't be 1 season = 1 book. Not sure if that's relevant for earlier seasons or whatever later seasons they have planned.

6-9 could be condensed to an episode and I'd be happy. Fuck those books. Rand boxquest is the worst.

Sterling · May 21, 2021

Furry said:
6-9 could be condensed to an episode and I'd be happy. Fuck those books. Rand boxquest is the worst.

Boxquest had an amazing ending though. 8-10 was the real bloat, 10 in particular.

Furry · May 21, 2021

Sterling said:
Boxquest had an amazing ending though. 8-10 was the real bloat, 10 in particular.

Oh yea, the ending was jizztastic, but the wait was not. I can't remember the books exactly with how long it's been since I read them, and I have no intention of reading them ever again, but wasn't he in that thing for an entire book and a half? If not it sure felt like it.

Deathwing · May 21, 2021

Furry said:
TBH I don't give a shit as long as he can act. Seeing that he's Perrin, all he has to do is act retarded and have big muscles and he'll play the role right. If he doesn't look like chef rush a few seasons in I'm gonna be disappoint.

A black guy that doesn't abandon his baby momma and doesn't tell his side ho to stfu? Perrin CANNOT be black.

Wheel of Time

Trakanon Raider

Egg Nazi

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X

Diet Dr. Pepper Enjoyer

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X

Email Loading Please Wait

Bronze Baronet of the Realm

Bronze Baronet of the Realm

El Presidente

Bronze Baronet of the Realm

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X

Email Loading Please Wait

Bronze Baronet of the Realm

Ahn'Qiraj Raider

Vyemm Raider

Email Loading Please Wait

El Presidente

Email Loading Please Wait