I have liked the dungeons so far even on heroic mode they are still pretty fun. A couple of them would have me a bit worried on how they are like on mythic+ but otherwise really pretty solid.
That's exactly what I was going to say. Like that mini boss in Atonement with all of the ghosts in the pews? Going to be a nightmare with some of the (affixes, hyperlinking is weird atm)
affixes even though right now its obnoxiously easy to do without them. Spiteful and Storming are just going to be a huge pain in the ass. Prideful for this season actually looks.. useful, at the same time bad which is cool.
I thoroughly enjoy the dungeons so far. Ive done atonement more times than I care to remember, and still dont mind going in there for another run. De Other Side is a bit annoying, but I feel like with solid Mythic+ groups - it wont be near as time consuming. Tirna Scithe or w/e is the only one that may be annoying to do time after time, only because people fail that dumb ass puzzle so much.
The Covenant bonuses in each one are nice, but only to a point. Some, like the Night Fae in Tirna Scithe are really good. They give that shortcut and a quick shroom to help you on your way. But as a tank, I feel like the Venthyr ones can eat a dick. People will go out of their way to aggro a group of mobs for that dumb ass Gargoyle. The lanterns are nice, but you should be able to pick them up and carry them a short distance. Necrolords are so rare that Im not even sure Ive seen anyone click those flags, and if they did - then its impact is unnoticeable. I have yet to see what, if any, Kyrian bonuses are in dungeons. All Ive seen in Kyrian dungeons that are impactful are those weapons/shields/hammers that you can pick up and they arent tied to any covenant (but god I love when people know where the spear is and when to use it).
I cant place my finger on it, but I hated every single BFA dungeon. I always felt like I was zig zagging all across the gd map. Some of the bosses didnt have great telegraphs, so any new player could wipe you. Felt like absolute tons of trash in every single one and the affixes were just straight aids. Legion had a lot of good dungeons - they could have changed Maw of Souls so you didnt run it so much but it was still a good dungeon. Vault of the Wardens was really the only one that I disliked. Didnt really hate it, but the dungeon had a knack for showing you how bad people were. Same kind of thing with WoD. I really liked those dungeons, but disliked the Orc ones. etc.