I do wonder "what next" for the Warcraft franchise as a whole.
WoW was my EQ. I barely touched eq for a month or two before grad school sucked me in. I came out of school at the tail end of Vanilla WoW. It holds a special spot for me. I didn't play a lot of PC stuff prior. The closest to impact for me is probably Legend of Zelda (specifically ALttP and OoT), FFIV (or FF2 US), and maybe SF2 for those games that just defined why I loved gaming. WoW was a game I could put anyone down in a chair and within 20 minutes they'd be a convert. It was just fun and exemplified why this hobby was great. I had similar experiences with Zelda and SF2. Just seeing the addiction grow in someone.
It's fun to toss around "shit show" about recent xpacs, but they've still delivered a decent amount of fun and been polished as hell. The cracks are showing though. It was sorta like Skyward Sword. It felt like Zelda. It was polished, but something wasn't hitting the nostalgia buttons or the joy buttons just right. It started to feel tired. That's where WoW clearly is right now.
A buddy asked me about Skyward Sword. I said it was good. I didn't regret my 40 or so hours. But I didn't feel that burning desire to do 100% of the game like even Twilight Princess. I summed it up with "what now?" I hate to see this franchise die, but I agree that a showing like WoD could spell doom. I feel Blizzard needs to step back and re-new fun somehow. That will involve risk, but I think we would welcome it.
Goddamn I'm talking about this like its the fate of the free world. I'm emotional.
I gave Nintendo my childhood through college years. I was a fanboy but they got my time. I did the same with Blizzard and my 20's and 30's. I played other stuff but I also skipped a lot of last console generation to give Blizzard my money and time. Damnit. Do right by us. Don't be like Nintendo and chase gimmicks. Make us be kids again. Salty fuck as I am.