So, I'm tired of commuting on my Fisher HiFi. I'm moving house so will be 9 miles each way (currently just over 6) and the MTB makes it a real slog, which means I don't do it as often as I should. The commute is 95% road/paved cycle path with a little bit of hard pack dirt at the start, new commute is basically same, just extra road tacked on at one end and if I wanted I could actually avoid the dirt bit entirely by doing an extra 1 mile loop.
Anyhow, after much research I decided a road focused cyclocross type bike would be my best bet, specifically I'm looking at
thisI did consider the Trek, Specialized and other brands of this type of bike but the spec is less for the same or more cash and Whyte bikes seem to get good reviews, this bike in particular. The price point is fixed as there is a UK cycle to work scheme that means you buy it from gross wages, so effectively it's tax free (so 32% discount) for bikes up to ?1k. I also ruled out the flat bar hybrids as I'm basically road based and ruled out a true road bike due to the shocking nature of roads around here, truing a wheel every day doesn't sound fun, plus I can stick mudguards and a shelf on this.
Now onto the question, a 54cm frame sits about 2cm below my family jewels, bloke in LBS reckons a 52 would be my size (long story short they had neither size in so I went and sat on the 54 at a different shop who tend to be not quite as helpful so would prefer the original shop, to sit on a 52 I have to get them to ship one in as neither shop had that size in stock). With my MTB I went small on the frame for the obvious reasons but I haven't ridden a road(ish) style bike for over 20 years so need a little advice. I did like the feel of the 54 as it was a comfortable reach to the bars and was a relatively upright ride (but still no MTB) and as I'm pushing 40 I just don't want to be hunched over some tiny little frame. The question (eventually) is this, should I be happy with the 54 or go to the effort of tracking down a 52 to sit on? As mentioned LBS guy recommended a 52 but that was before I sat on the 54 at a different shop.
Cheers
edit: oh yeah I'm 5'10" if that helps for the choice between 52 and 54cm frame (I like to mix my metric and Imperial)