Community
- Thread starter gogusrl
- Start date
Azrayne
Irenicus did nothing wrong
- 2,161
- 786
Harmon was there for S3, and that's where things started to go downhill for me. It wasn't as bad as 4, but it had a fair few really bad episodes, especially towards the end with the whole 'Chang takes over the school' storyline. S3 is where it really went off the deep end, they just gave up on any pretense of the show being based around real people in the real world. It also had some really good episodes, don't get me wrong, but they completely lost the balance between reality and the references/parodies/quirky meta-ness that they managed to maintain over the first two seasons and the whole show, to paraphrase the show itself, shoved itself up it's own ass.
I'm not even going to touch on how terrible S4 was, but I don't see how they can come back from it, especially with the kind of BS they're going to have to pull just to get Jeff back at Greendale.
I'm not even going to touch on how terrible S4 was, but I don't see how they can come back from it, especially with the kind of BS they're going to have to pull just to get Jeff back at Greendale.
Bondurant
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 3,837
- 4,786
Yeah, it's not like he's the one responsible for Community's rushed writing, on-the-fly rewritten scripts and ego dramas.
Grimmlokk
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 12,190
- 132
Or every single one of it's best episodes?
This season is gonna happen no matter what, might as well hope for the best. If we get a couple episodes on par with the better ones from season 3 I'll be happy. Well, I mean, pleasantly surprised anyways.
We like to shit on season 3 because that's where it started to run out of steam, but that's also the season that gave us one of the best sitcom episodes of all time. Remedial Chaos Theory. The season was very uneven, probably a reflection of all the on-set drama that was happening. HOWEVER it also had some absolute classic episodes.
This season is gonna happen no matter what, might as well hope for the best. If we get a couple episodes on par with the better ones from season 3 I'll be happy. Well, I mean, pleasantly surprised anyways.
We like to shit on season 3 because that's where it started to run out of steam, but that's also the season that gave us one of the best sitcom episodes of all time. Remedial Chaos Theory. The season was very uneven, probably a reflection of all the on-set drama that was happening. HOWEVER it also had some absolute classic episodes.
Wombat
Trakanon Raider
- 2,031
- 795
Season 3 is a pretty strong litmus test for how committed you are to the show.
Chaos Theory, Horror Fiction, Holiday Music, Lupine Urology, and Digital Estate Planning are pretty great episodes that were entertaining to casual fans.
The Dreamtorium and Chang Takeover bits require a much higher level of involvement.
Chaos Theory, Horror Fiction, Holiday Music, Lupine Urology, and Digital Estate Planning are pretty great episodes that were entertaining to casual fans.
The Dreamtorium and Chang Takeover bits require a much higher level of involvement.
Grimmlokk
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 12,190
- 132
Yeah but the Chang thing gave us this, which has made me uncomfortable with how aroused it makes me.
Rengak
Blackwing Lair Raider
- 2,879
- 2,761
You think you know someone. The image I thought you would have posted from that episode is this.
Cantatus
Lord Nagafen Raider
- 1,437
- 79
Eh, maybe losing Pierce and Troy will end up being a good thing. Season 3 started to go downhill because they got too comfortable. Harmon seems the type that works best under pressure. The first two seasons were so great because he was struggling to figure the show out and trying to get ratings, where he just got a little comfortable with season 3 since everything had been established. Perhaps a shake-up will force him to have to approach the show differently, allowing it to regain some of the quality from earlier on.
Grimmlokk
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 12,190
- 132
Azrayne
Irenicus did nothing wrong
- 2,161
- 786
That image right there is everything I hate about S3.
That's a load of crap. It's not about the level of involvement or how committed you are, the show just flat out drifted off into lala land. Season 1 & 2 had a lot of quirkiness, but other than a few things here and there which pushed the boundaries (the Paintball episodes being the biggest ones), it was for the most part taking place in the closest thing TV has to reality. The characters felt as much like real people as you get in a TV series, Greendale, mostly, kinda, felt like a real place, at least in a TV adapted, maybe slightly unreliable narrator-esque way. And even when it did push the boundaries, the good writing and acting kept it grounded, because the show acknowledged the weirdness even as it went along with it, and because it always came back down to earth a bit.
IMO, the problem probably started with the Paintball episodes, and how popular they were. They took something that was awesome because it was different, because it contrasted with the normal mood of the show, and started making every episode and plotline in that manner. Like Cantatus said, they probably got comfortable, 'oh, the viewers like weird unrealistic fantasy scenarios and parodies that would never happen in the real world? We'll give them tons of it!' But those episodes were good because they were rare, they only worked as a contrast to the regular reality the rest of the episodes took place in, when they became the norm the show just completely diverted from that reality and became some kind of weird fantasy trip.
That said, despite not generally being a fan of how far out of reality the show went in S3, it wasn't all bad. Remedial Chaos Theory has already been mentioned, and I also liked the episode with Annie and Abed in the Dreamatorium. But even then, compare it to the Season 1 episode where Britta pays for Abed to start taking film classes. Both episodes are about Abed reflecting on his ability to relate to the people around him and the fears which stem from that (interestingly, the episode in S1 is about his fears about the past, and the S3 episode is about his fears of the future), but while the season 1 episode involves Abed using a handheld camera to film people as he wanders around campus, then cutting the clips together and editing them to play out and express his worries, Season 3 involves Abed and Annie running through some shared hallucinatory dreamland, jumping in and out of parodies and scenarios taken from other shows. Both deal with the same theme, but in wildly different ways which demonstrate how much the tone of the show had changed in S3.
If you want another example, look at the intro to the first episode of S2 & S3. S2 has the characters jumping out of bed, getting changed etc, in a montage with music played over the top, while S3 has an extended fantasy song and dance CGI sequence.
None of that crap is bad because it's complicated, or difficult to understand unless you're 'committed' enough, it's bad because it's a massive shift in the tone of the series which makes the characters and their experiences impossible to relate to. I can relate to and sympathize with Abed using his creativity to circumvent his inability to communicate with the people around him and expressing his feelings about his family to his father through a video clip which he's put together, much, much more than I can understand or relate to him making an emotional breakthrough because he spent an afternoon playing make believe hopping through shared imaginary dreamscape TV show parodies. Everything that happened in that S1 episode could have happened to a real person, in real life. The S3 episode? Not so much.
This is a great analysis. I agree that part of the problem Community started to experience is that it went too far out of reality too often. Re-watching the earlier seasons on Comedy Central has convinced me of this. The show just feels more grounded for Season 1 and 2. Yes, Remedial Chaos Theory is one of the best episodes of the show and sitcom television in general, but it's clear the show started slipping in season 3 by going too far from reality.
