I picked it Comrade!
I like a bit of random, always have, yeah it sucks when you get spluched but it is awesome when you splortch the enemy. People always scream that it lacks skill but shit happens in a fight, it is not all scripted out and choreographed, sometimes that punch you threw gets deflected into their throat and crushes their windpipe. Yay you!
I want a game where if you hate crits you have a strategy to deal with it. You gear for it, you spec for it, but of course in doing so you are vulnerable to something else. And then when you crush that punk ass build of the critmaester class it feels good!