Tyen said:
There are "joke" pages that start out with the like farms and then grow into legitimate pages. So there are examples of them getting actual popularity over time.
Yeah, that"s true. I was just thinking about it from a startup perspective -- betting the house on a page with farmed likes as a way to reach customers just doesn"t seem like an effective way to go about it.
Then again, I know jack and shit about advertising. Out of curiosity, what"s the sales pitch you"d make to someone like me who"s got sound technical knowledge and decent business sense for these likes? I"m just having trouble understanding how farmed likes translate into actual fans or users -- is it just priming the pump, or does the amount of likes gain you extra visibility on Facebook itself even though the accounts liking them lack an actual network of people to reach with those likes?
FB could take down the like farms, but so far they have only been taking out the ones that sell likes for USD.
My concern is less about you as a singular entity (or any other single small scale operation), and Facebook going lawyer-happy if/when farmed likes devalue the concept of "liking" something on a social network and they feel the need to protect their value proposition to businesses looking to use Facebook as their hub in the social realm.
Silence said:
Tyen is smart and entertaining and maybe pretty enterprising, too...but rest assured knowing that what he is doing isn"t on the radar of shit to take care of at FB.
Like I said in the portion of the post above this quote, I"m less worried that Tyen will get himself sued for doing anything in a vacuum, and more concerned that this sort of operation when either scaled up to the size of a full-time business or when done by thousands of people that see the opportunity Tyen does will devalue "likes", and cause Facebook to go sue-happy to try to defend the worth of social endorsements.
I"ll also admit that I could be worrying for no reason -- that"s just how I"d look at it from Facebook"s perspective.
Silence said:
Also, no CSI C&D stuff. They"d just drop a banhammer on him and everything he"s doing if it was important.
A banhammer"s useless when each new account is created from a new IP, or an already verified account is purchased. If you"re not doing user curation like Req does where every new poster has to be approved for full board posting access, and Facebook isn"t, all they"re doing is filling up a blacklist.
And if Tyen was really wading into deep water, Gummint Folk with Stern Looks and Mormon Haircuts would be pulling his ears out of their sockets.
I can"t think of a law he"s breaking by doing this unless the government tried to stick some iteration of wire fraud charge, and that"d be ridiculously hard to make stick. It"s more along the lines of Tyen and other people in his boat not actually having the cash to fight Facebook in court if they receive a C&D letter.
Really, I"m just more curious about this whole setup than anything else, given how prevalent social ______ is in the IT industry right now.