After having about 24 hrs to reflect on what I saw yesterday, I have to say that I'm not impressed.
Visually, it looks great with cool animations and interesting environments. The engine seems sound and looks like it encapsulates a lot of really innovative tech. I just have a real problem with the lack of eveything else. I thought, after the reveal, that there would be more shown. You know, like an actual game... a starting area... a dungeon... something. Rather we were treated to a lot of armchair development interviews, with developers saying really curious things like "that would be neat" or "we're not going to talk about that yet". Call me cynical, but I got a real Vanguard-vibe about it.
This "game" sounds great on paper, but we've seen jack shit so far. In 4 years, SoE has managed to put together a great looking tech demo. Whoop-dee-fuck. I'm very skeptical if even half of what I'm hearing from these guys is even remotely true and, even if it is, I'm even more skeptical that SoE can pull it together without stepping on their dick. Remember, these are the clowns that tout one of the key EQ2 expansion features as being a fix to an existing feature that has been in the game for years and has never been fixed. Have we completely forgot who we're talking about around here?