Gogo and Umaro are the auto-excludes, Umaro is just terrible and Gogo can't equip espers.
lol @ leaving out Locke when he could probably just solo one path of the tower.
Locke can solo one path of the tower? How?
If Locke can solo one path, then most characters can solo one path. Which is true with proper min/maxing. I once had Cyan solo one path with level 99 and octa-slash relics.
I never found Locke to be a standout among the cast power-wise, outside of keeping him lower-level and giving him ValiantKnife/Offering. Which was more of a fun novelty build than anything else.
Umaro, Gogo, and Setzer are probably the most leave-behindable characters for Kefka's Tower. And out of those, Umaro with the Snow Muffler or whatever it is can wreck in Group 1. I like Gogo's look a lot, but yeah. Poor Setzer is just blah. I think Relm might also be a bit on the low end of the spectrum, but I think I turned her into a very good spellcaster last time.
Pretty much any character in FF6 can be great or OP if you put the effort into them.
Final Stats:
FF1 - 12:01 Play Time
Lv47 White Mage/Warrior/Thief/Black Mage
Now maybe run FF1 with 2x Red Mage and 2x Monk to experience the rest of the classes. That'd actually be a really solid party, since RM is possibly the best in the first half and falls off a bit endgame, while Monk is weak in the first half and probably the best endgame. The RMs could use AOEs in the early-game to carry things, and RM expensive-ness would be offset by the two Monks needing basically nothing.
Man, I've run FF1 so many different times now that it's easily my most-played FF. And it was never my favorite, plus I didn't even own it until like 1999. It just ended up being the one I revisit the most.
Oh yeah, my 4x White Mage run has been on hold for a couple weeks, but I reached the final dungeon. Level 32 on everyone which might be too low, but we'll see whenever I muster up some energy to finish the job. That's pretty much the last FF1 party I wanted to try.
I've beaten FF1 with:
-4x Fighter
-4x Red Mage (twice, one on NES and one on PS1)
-4x Thief (the hardest, on NES)
-4x Monk
-4x Black Mage (twice, one on NES and one on Pixel Remaster)
-3x Fighter and 1x White Mage (go-to as a kid after realizing how OP Fighter was)
-2x Fighter and 2x Red Mage
-2x Monk and 2x Red Mage
-2x Thief and 2x Black Mage
-Fighter, Thief, Monk, White Mage
-Fighter, Monk, Red Mage, White Mage (probably my favorite party)
-Fighter, Red Mage, 2x Monk
So that's 14 playthroughs and I'm probably forgetting a couple. Only other FF to come close is FF6 which I've played roughly 5-7 times.