Not quite a pixel remaster question, maybe we should change the thread to all things FF? but another question in my quest to replay all FF 1 -> X(skipping 11 as it's online and I have tried it and I always come in and out of FFXIV the other online one).
I learned from interwebs and this thread that FFVII Remake Intergrade is not just a rework like pixel remaster but a new/different game based on the same story. Is that also the case with the FFVIII and FFVII Remastered?
The only ones I am skipping are:
- FFIV After Years(for now, I may actually suck it up and go back to do this)
- DISSIDIA: Apparently a gotcha type iphone game that has no player base anymore, gets total shit reviews, etc. Unless someone from here speaks up no plans to do this
- The 3D remakes of 3/4 since they are just 3D remakes and I did the pixel remaster versions
- I have tried WOTV but not really my thing and another ipad style game
- I am currently playing FF7EC(the new ipad one) but I can easily see myself getting bored of the standard ipad gatcha style game after a month or two
- I tried Brave Exvius but it's the same as the other two phone games above
- Loved Record Keeper until they closed the servers and I can't be bothered to pretend to be from Korea or whatever region is still online, sounds complicated to do that crap
- Played Dimensions but that also seemed like a never-ending phone game
Basically my main question is about FF8 above, but curious if I am incorrect on any of those never ending phone games being worth the effort. I am looking to play the ones that start and finish outside of FF14
There's a general FF thread like Denamian said and in the future we should put general FF questions there. Might even want to let this thread sorta go by the wayside since very few people are still playing the Pixel Remasters at this point. So any further questions you should put there:
Since there was some danger of this derail in the ars editors thread, I thought I would divert the discussion over here in Rerolled's first ever Final Fantasy thread. That being said, every Final Fantasy that has come out since the Super Nintendo is garbage. I'm referring to the RPG line, so...
www.firesofheaven.org
I'll try to answer the questions here anyway as someone who's done the "start with FF1 and play all of them" twice now (once when FF10 was the latest one and once when FF13 was the latest one).
-I think it's worth playing the original versions of things...to an extent. Mostly it's FF1 on the NES that I'd say is worth playing for the historical value. The rest you could go PR for sure. FF1 PR is very different from FF1 NES (and much easier). Might want to do FF1 on NES just to see the genesis, then the PR version. FF1's so short that playing it twice isn't the worst thing, especially changing up the party lineup to try all the classes. Just leave Thief for the PR because it's awful on the NES.
-FF7 Remake is a different game based on the same story yes. FF8 Remastered is just an HD version of FF8. Same goes for FF9 HD.
-The 3D remakes of 3 and 4 are good, but I don't consider them the optimal versions or anything. They were better in the 2000's when their polygonal visuals didn't stick out like a sore thumb. FF4 3D's augment system is really cool but yeah. It's more of a "master quest" of FF4 IMO. I'd skip them unless one is really on a "do everything" run.
-FF Dimensions is basically just FF5-2 isn't it? I played it for a few hours and really liked it, didn't strike me as a phone game. I assume it has a normal arc and end point and isn't a gacha of any sort.
-World of Final Fantasy on the PS4 is actually a really good game that hardly anyone seems to know about. It's basic and simplistic, like a beginner's first RPG sort of thing, but it has a massive amount of nostalgia in it for the world and characters of the series.
-What I'd do at this point is FF1 NES, then the six PRs, then FF7/8/9/10/10-2/12 HD versions on PS4, then wrap up with FF7 Remake. The 13 trilogy, 15, and 16 are all really divisive and the latter two are action games, so not sure if I'd even bother with all of those even though I liked the 13 games a lot myself. 12 is a very high note to end on. If on a "do everything" run and have the time, then I'd add 13 trilogy, World of Final Fantasy, and 3/4 3D before 15/16.
-After Years is actually worth playing after FF1-6. I'd emulate the PSP version. The Wii version has the charming SNES aesthetic, but if you're playing the PR FF4 then that aesthetic means very little. PSP version is much prettier. Just be warned that TAY's final dungeon is like half of the game and can really drag. A lot of it is fanservice with returning bosses from 1-6 (which is why I'd suggest playing it after all of those).
-If you don't care a ton about beating all of said games, you could call it with TAY whenever it starts dragging. Same with FF1 NES if you get the gist of it, 13 if you don't like it, etc.
-No matter what I'd leave FF7 Remake for last. A lot of us here aren't crazy about that game. It's FF7 with much better (modern) visuals but it also goes off on new story detours and tangents. Plus there's a sequel on the way and leaving it for last gives that time to drop.