Not sure how anyone can say the combat in this feels good. It feels 'fine' but it's still just slow ass wow-clone combat. Yeah you have lots of off GCDs, but your gcd is a year and a half so it might as well just be wow AT BEST. Animation locking stuff still sucks ass and feels clunky.
Game is fine, low level questing is boring but the storyline legitimately got interesting towards late ARR and I loved Heavensward, but all the dungeons and raids are only worth seeing once tops, yet they force you to grind like crazy.
If they want to retain people better in the next xpac, they should probably launch it with more than 2 endgame dungeons that you grind over and over. If I never see Neverreap again I'll be happy, and Fractal is better for its music than its gameplay. I know there's more since then, but the problem is worse than wow/warlords "nothing to do at cap" ever was.