MTG thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Brahma

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
12,750
47,747
Honestly I would just buy some preconstructed boxed commander decks from an MTG store (WoTC precons) and learn the game before you spend money on custom stuff or start collecting crazy amounts. You won't know what you like until you learn to play and face a bunch of different deck archetypes.

I think they are like $40-50 each or something like that.

Thanks for the info, appreciate it. Any beginner friendly deck you reccomend?
 

Palum

what Suineg set it to
27,706
44,310
Thanks for the info, appreciate it. Any beginner friendly deck you reccomend?
I haven't played in a long time so not sure what has come out recently or will be in stock, but get a couple precons that have themes you like and just learn to play first. Also depending what stores you go to they may have all sorts of older ones still in stock that speak to you.

Generally colors are aligned this way:

White: buff/protection/healing
Blue: counters/tricks/spells
Red: burn/attack creatures
Green: tokens/big creatures/creature buffs
Black: sacrifice/power/discard/mill

So commanders color palette dictates sorta what themes they use above. So Red/Green will likely be something along the lines of aggressive creatures and burn/growth spells.

Precons are meant to be generally straightforward and a good way to learn the basics of the game, so while there are all sorts of crazy off-color effects and way more nuance, you get a feel just by reading the tin what the deck is good for.

IMO a good FLGS is worth finding so I would drive around or find one and patronize them if the opportunity exists.
 

Brahma

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
12,750
47,747
I haven't played in a long time so not sure what has come out recently or will be in stock, but get a couple precons that have themes you like and just learn to play first. Also depending what stores you go to they may have all sorts of older ones still in stock that speak to you.

Generally colors are aligned this way:

White: buff/protection/healing
Blue: counters/tricks/spells
Red: burn/attack creatures
Green: tokens/big creatures/creature buffs
Black: sacrifice/power/discard/mill

So commanders color palette dictates sorta what themes they use above. So Red/Green will likely be something along the lines of aggressive creatures and burn/growth spells.

Precons are meant to be generally straightforward and a good way to learn the basics of the game, so while there are all sorts of crazy off-color effects and way more nuance, you get a feel just by reading the tin what the deck is good for.

IMO a good FLGS is worth finding so I would drive around or find one and patronize them if the opportunity exists.

Great. There are quite a few stores near me. Will stop by.
 

Chris

Potato del Grande
19,736
-10,549
I know zero about MTG other than learning the play via video's and what these guys keep running into my office telling me. This group of guys play Commander games here after work in the conference room. I always wanted to try playing MTG, so I figured this was a great chance to learn. Figured this commander was a playstyle I don't mind.

I don't know enough about the game, and the card synergies etc to make my own deck yet, Figured I'd buy a deck and tweak it as needed as I learn.

I don't mind spending the extra money if it saves me time, effort, and headache.
It's not a good time to fully jump in, the game is in late stage woke cash grab territory right now.

Ask the guys you work with what the power level of their decks is and limit yourself to one similar power deck to play with them and limit your financial liability for now.

Like are they using a store bought deck, something they made themselves from boosters, something reasonably priced they copied from the internet or max power cards?

Just buy what you need.

Also get a vibe for the kinds of decks they play. Are they having long games attacking with creatures, or comboing out in a few turns? Do they get to play their cards or is there a lot of counterspells and kill cards?

You don't want to show up with a weak deck and get crushed, or destroy them with a powerful/unfun deck and ruin their fun.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

OneofOne

Silver Baronet of the Realm
6,952
8,815
Funnily enough I just bought many of those vampire cards for one of my own commander decks. $250 is certainly on the high side for that and you're really just paying (a lot) for the convenience of someone already having all the cards in one place.

If I may suggest some purchase options. The first has 4 commander decks, at least 2 of which are good, and one is a vampire deck. The second link is to another recent set of 4 commander decks. They're so so, but it's a really good price for all 4 and lets you try different things. Third set is another 4 commander decks from a recent set, on a plane with sentient animals (mostly bats, rabbits, rats, raccoons, etc) in case that's not your thing. Fun decks though.



 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Brahma

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
12,750
47,747
I grabbed Lord of the Rings commander deck (Just to have it) , and a zombie deck which I think I will like.


 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user