Obi-Wan Kenobi

Chukzombi said:

i was really just referring to Yoda when we saw him. i dont think that was his prime, his prime was probably 400 years earlier. he could have wiped up the floor with Palps or Vader. who knows, maybe both at once. by the time he faces Dukuu, he had a little more zest in him and Yoda was forced to do a bunch of hopping around to keep up with him which probably tired the fuck out of him. it looks like Siddious is fucking with Yoda, he isnt taking him very seriously. you can see Yoda on the defense the entire time and after the fall he just has that "i'm getting too old for this shit" expression and scoots. Siddious was way too powerful for him or anyone else during that moment.

also, they really made Yoda look like shit in the prequels

also also, George tried to retcon the OT into kiddie films by adding dumb shit years later. it was always an "all audiences" film it was never for kids until he did the prequels and that was a crutch for him being a corny fucker. most of that wasnt kid oriented. just corny characters thrown in, like Jar Jar.

Click to expand...

It was of course designed to sell toys in the end yep.

Gavinmad said:

Ep 3 commentary. McDiarmid may be referring to the way he plays possum after Windu beats him, but he definitely needs Anakin to save him from Mace.

Click to expand...

Yes maybe that's what Mcdirmid said. Makes sense.

shabushabu said:

It was of course designed to sell toys in the end yep.

Click to expand...

nothing has changed

Blitz said:

Guys. I'm on episode 6 now.

This is bad. Did they film this for 7 year olds? I can't understand how someone signs off on this...

Edit: Just finished this series. What was the point? It sucked. It was very childish. The story had promise, but no surprise. The only. solid scene was Anakin speaking through the broken helmet.

Just garbage. Disney should be set on fire with all the executives inside. Dune wasn't perfect but watch this comparatively, and it's x10 more mature, and more interesting. Rogue One is such an outlier, what a shame.

Click to expand...

I feel like a lot of you guys have never seen Star Wars before.

It's Hero's Journey in space with a bunch of wacky shit from George Lucas like the gay robots who are in every movie, guerilla warfare with teddy bears and comedy fish men.

It's a fable you turn your brain off for and enjoy the spectacle. If you want something intelligent you watch Star Trek.

Chris said:

I feel like a lot of you guys have never seen Star Wars before.

It's Hero's Journey in space with a bunch of wacky shit from George Lucas like the gay robots who are in every movie, guerilla warfare with teddy bears and comedy fish men.

It's a fable you turn your brain off for and enjoy the spectacle. If you want something intelligent you watch Star Trek.

Click to expand...

well said sir.

Also it's kind of funny how much they ripped off the Vader vs Ahsoka scene for the Vader vs Obi-Wan scene. Same helmet damage, similar dialogue (but delivered better in Rebels), and same voice synthesizer damage stuttering between Anakin voice and Vader voice.

Chris said:

If you want something intelligent you watch Star Trek.

Click to expand...

uhhhhhh

Gavinmad said:

Also it's kind of funny how much they ripped off the Vader vs Ahsoka scene for the Vader vs Obi-Wan scene. Same helmet damage, similar dialogue (but delivered better in Rebels), and same voice synthesizer damage stuttering between Anakin voice and Vader voice.


uhhhhhh

Click to expand...

Yeah well with my Star Trek comment, not the movies, Picard or Discovery obviously.

Normal people don't watch those cartoons, so it's a good testing ground for what will be popular in live action.

I've also read that Ashoka and Obi-Wan break opposite sides of the mask, with only Luke being able to figuratively get rid of the entire mask. Sounds just fine to me.

the boys at corridor made their weekly fx react video, and Wren, i think pointed out that you can often forgive bad acting or bad special effects if the story is immersive enough and if the those things are in service to the story. in the original trilogy (less so with ROTJ, as per the whole ewoks thing) we can get passed all the plates we see around the tie fighters, the transparent cockpit in the snow speeders, the wooden acting from several main characters throughout... because they they are all in service to a great (albeit often simple) story.

when people say that star wars has ALWAYS had poor dialogue/acting/whatever, it's true, but it misses the fact that the story (and how it was edited) itself was good enough and engaging enough and cohesive enough that you forgive A LOT of those issues. that's what has been missing from the series (not including the cartoons) since the original trilogy. i give lucas credit for trying to make a different kind of set of movies with the prequal trilogy, but the story itself is a mess. we can't get engaged enough to ignore the issues, so we end up focusing on them. which is the EXACT same issue with disney's star wars. less so with mando, though i'd say there are still story beats that take too long to explore so it drags on in certain places...

obi-wan had some great moments, i think we all generally agree with that... it's just the rest of the 5 hours of the show hardly made any sense. it kind of feels like one of the driving forces of the storytellers was to purposely tangle up continuity to get people watching to see how they will (or IF they will) straighten it out at the end.

Blitz said:

Something like that.

You can make what you described, and make it a good piece of cinema - this is not that. If you enjoy these new movies from Disney, you have terrible taste. They've made Star Wars nothing special at all, never thought they could tank an IP this intriguing, this fast. It's objectively bad entertainment.

Click to expand...

It’s all about marketing to new demographics. See action figures above lol

Phazael said:

Lucas has demonstrated time and again he does not understand his own work. I mean, Palps is fucking laughing the entire time he is laying down the ass beating on Yoda and was a trained deceiver. He never would have allowed himself to be there unguarded if he expected Mace to pose an actual threat. Han shot first anyone?

Click to expand...

Aside from that clear moment of fear when he realizes that Yoda is a more powerful force wielder than him?

Your version of Palpatine is a cringeworthy power-fantasy where in addition to being a peerless manipulator and politician, he's absolutely invincible as a force wielder.

it's just silly that swtor, an mmo, did a much better palpatine with valkorian than basically anything else. palpatine in episode 9 was a poor man's valkorian, and even had the force lightning into the sky done SIGNIFICANTLY better in the game. i mean, even the plot of palpatine getting killed by rey specifically to be reborn into her was identical to the game, but the game had the balls to actually go through with it.

i'm still just baffled by how much the movie ripped off the game and how utterly it failed at it.

Gavinmad said:

Aside from that clear moment of fear when he realizes that Yoda is a more powerful force wielder than him?

Your version of Palpatine is a cringeworthy power-fantasy where in addition to being a peerless manipulator and politician, he's absolutely invincible as a force wielder.

Click to expand...

except Palpy is completely insane and has absolutely no fucks to give and has no stakes he's worried about losing. that shit makes him incredibly dangerous on top of being immensely powerful in the Force. Yoda ran scared.

Star wars died in 1999. You all need to accept it and move on.

Chukzombi said:

except Palpy is completely insane and has absolutely no fucks to give and has no stakes he's worried about losing. that shit makes him incredibly dangerous on top of being immensely powerful in the Force. Yoda ran scared.

Click to expand...

The stakes are literally CONTROL OF THE ENTIRE GALAXY. And Yoda didn't run scared, he simply lost. It's like when two fighters clash heads and only one guy gets a bad cut. Doesn't mean he was the worse fighter.