Plenty of reasons. Poor gameplay, poor updating, poor world building, etc, etc,etc. Just depends on the game. EQ became a ghost town, Vanguard was always a ghost town, etc, etc, etc. The only game that hasn't become a ghost town is WoW so they win? There is little factual evidence to support your stance just like there is little factual support that people don't want another EQ. The one fact is that some people are desperate enough to support a con man just to get that game(I know it's been mentioned). I just don't see it. He has never shown that kind of success without heavy support(any success really).