I wish I had a solution. Well, I do, but it's huge amounts of oragel, and I don't want to get yelled at again.We are having serious issues with bedtime with my two oldest girls now. They share a bed and it is frustrating as fuck trying to get them to go to bed because they feed each other's energy. We did that whole Supernanny thing when they were each in their own room, but now that they share a room that shit doesn't work, they think it's a game. Idk, working on it.
Am I the only one who forces my kids to watch shows just so I can watch them? I forced them to watch Yo Gabba Gabba and now Aquabats, those shows are awesome.
I've not had the bedtime trouble you have. A really, really regular routine helped me avoid it. I also didn't have two sharing a bed until sleeping patterns were well established. I know this is a shitty, shitty option, but what if you guys take it in turns to sit IN the room at bed time until sleep happens. It wouldn't be forever, and a week or two of this might solve the problem.
That said, keep this in mind - you're not a bad parent. Even if you make them watch crap tv.