Yeah, I remember Digg dying. I feel like a lot of these sites think they're invincible. It's kind of fun when it finally crumbles around them and they realize how badly they fucked up and destroyed something good.
Yeah, once you're on top for long enough it seems it really goes to your head.
/Kn0thing'scomments are like watching that realization in real time, it's actually amazing. He goes from his popcorn comment and laughing at people to now profusely apologizing, and vowing to improve communication.
In any case, unless something changes, Reddit is close to done--not because of this, but because it has some major standing issues. The Toolbox sub forum illustrates it really well, most of the communication/mod tools are out of date, and a host of other issues, there is just very little care it seems to improve the site, and user concerns are mocked outright as if they were just whiners (Until now, obviously.)
Edit: No idea if this is true, but it explains a lot.
Sup qg... Several of our old mutual friends have been keeping me in the loop and from what they have been saying things are not looking good at reddit HQ. The higher ups (executives and board members) at reddit are totally out of touch with the community, kn0thing included sadly. Ellen Pao barely even knows how to use reddit, let alone truly understand what makes it tick and what it needs to survive and the vast majority of the new hires rarely (if ever) interact with the community like the admins of old. And to top it off most of the current admins aren't even webdevs, software engineers or community team members hired from within the community anymore... they are outside hires, mostly marketers and middle management. Does all this sound familiar? This sort of non-core site functions staff bloat and loss of touch with the community is literally the exact same thing that happened at digg before v4. Apparently this all started with Yishan's retarded plan to close the NYC office (which may be why Victoria was fired, since she was the last remaining admin in NYC) and force all the remote working admins (other than those outside the US) to relocate to SF or be fired, which caused an exodus of talent and generated a lot of resentment even by the staff that were willing/able to move. The mood in the SF office has supposedly gotten steadily worse since then too thanks to some of Pao's bizarre decisions regarding hiring (she refused to honor several of Yishan's hires despite the fact they had already quit their jobs to join reddit), restructuring (can't say much other than she seriously fucked several long-term employees over.. don't want anyone to get in trouble) and salary negotiations (according to her, women can't negotiate as well as men so nobody is allowed to negotiate their salaries anymore). Damnit... I really wish spez would come back and sort this shit out. ...sigh...
I believe him on the Pao aspects...she's, more than once, illustrated she does not know how to use Reddit; she tried to link her own inbox ect. She's highly intelligent, mind you, it just seems like she doesn't even care to learn. Which again, makes sense, she's there to put lipstick on the pig before selling it....it would explain all of her short term thinking.