The Girls Who Broke Your Heart Thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,847
100,130
That won't matter, he can still lose a ton of shit. Plus you don't know, this guy could flip his shit and kill one of them, he could forgive her and stay with her, they could stay together in many different scenarios. You can either flake on her and just cut her off and hope for the best, or try to just explain that you don't think you want to do this anymore knowing she's married. Hopefully in either situation she lets it die. Numbers has to go to school at this place, if he can walk away without any trouble its the best for him.
Uh the whole being killed by the other guy has been a possibility for the past year for numbers. And still a very real possibility even after its ended.

Imo, tell the guy anonymously after you record a conversation or two or her saying its 100% consensual and all that.
 

Numbers_sl

shitlord
4,054
3
Uh the whole being killed by the other guy has been a possibility for the past year for numbers. And still a very real possibility even after its ended.

Imo, tell the guy anonymously after you record a conversation or two or her saying its 100% consensual and all that.
How could it not be 100% consensual for over a year?
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
107
It couldn't, you're talking to a bunch of fucking virgins who have never even seen a woman before.

Like I said, put anyone (even yourself) else in that situation and I'm sure you'd want to be told if your wife is cheating on you.
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
107
It's irrelevant what I've done, we're not talking about me. We're talking about your fucked up life.
 

iannis

Musty Nester
31,351
17,657
I'm sure most everyone would want to be told. I don't think numbers has a responsibility to tell him. I believe him, he really didn't know. She was just a friendly hook up. You don't go around looking gift horses in the mouth.

But if it's a hookup that's been going on for a year... that raises some questions about what their relationship actually is like. Questions that he can't answer. You're not gonna be able to trust a fucking word she says about it, and you're not going to be able to get his take on it...

Tell the husband don't tell him. It's a risk either way, and it's not numbers responsibility (yet) to take that risk on. You stick your dick in her again and it IS your responsbility. But right now -- you can break this clean.

Telling him might turn out to be the right thing to do. Telling him might turn out to have been the wrong thing to do. Can't really know. That he would want to be told, sure. I think most guys would.
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
107
I think that pretty much answers the question there. Do what you'd want done to yourself is the philosophy that I live by.
 

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,665
16,110
I gotta agree that I'd want to know if it was my wife. And as an added bonus, telling me without being caught would definitely save your life.
 

moonarchia

The Scientific Shitlord
24,552
46,249
Everyone would want to know, and everyone would want to murder the other guy regardless of any other details. It's not something numbers should be doing while he has to be anywhere near the guy or his slutty wife ever again.
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
107
Why on earth would you want to murder the other guy? Especially given the circumstances, this was entirely the woman's fault and any rational person can see that pretty clearly.
 

Gravy

Bronze Squire
4,918
454
Why on earth would you want to murder the other guy? Especially given the circumstances, this was entirely the woman's fault and any rational person can see that pretty clearly.
Yeah, but humans get all irrational when ownership of poontang comes into question. Most of the time, cooler heads prevail. Most.
 

Famm

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
11,041
794
Everyone says "you'd want someone to tell you" especially online. But in reality the phrase "he was the last to know" is much more prevalent, and it stands to reason when you look at people's interactions. There's a hell of a lot of dynamics that come into play and its never usually so easy as your best friend having rock solid evidence and letting you know the deal. Especially with wives and shit. More often there are multiple people's lives and interests intertwined as well as tons of plausible deniability and people rationalizing that something could just be a rumor.

I've been on every side of this situation, I'll admit, and pretty much every single time it gets exposed because of either a guilty party admitting, a suspicious party investigating or someone involved just simply fucking up and blowing the subterfuge. Sometimes crazy shit like an affair getting too attached/crazy and letting the wife/husband know they are going to take the spouse from them. I've never known it to be a matter of "hey bro, I gotta tell you something" followed by a rational assessment of the situation and responsive course of action.

Maybe in HS or college there would be a "dude she's banging that other guy wtf" and even then drama follows despite everyone being immature beer drinking idiots who in retrospect had little to gain or lose in the long run. But for adults there's so much at stake from jobs, marriages, children, friendships between couples/mutual friendships....people manage to rationalize away letting things go on under the radar and hope for the best rather than be involved in the nuclear war that's percolating.

In thisparticularcase, I can't even imagine what you're asking Numbers to do. "Hey, you don't know me but I'm a student here, and I've been banging you're wife for the past year. But I'm totally going to stop now since I found out you're married. Have a good day!" WTF, seriously?
 

Aaron

Goonsquad Officer
<Bronze Donator>
8,946
21,172
Kristen - home with mom, off drugs....living clean ( gave me gonorrhea )
Jamie - home with boyfriend at his sisters, off drugs....living clean ( gave me gonorrhea )
Capri - see her every day to help her out, she went home to her moms last night, but called me to tell me shes back in drug-ville and wants to meet up tonite...
I must have missed out on one. Kristen was the Camden whore with the boyfriend/pimp you helped rent a home for, right? Then she got knocked up.
Jamie - is she the tent-city smack whore? Or is that Capri?

I'm confused.
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
107
Everyone says "you'd want someone to tell you" especially online. But in reality the phrase "he was the last to know" is much more prevalent, and it stands to reason when you look at people's interactions. There's a hell of a lot of dynamics that come into play and its never usually so easy as your best friend having rock solid evidence and letting you know the deal. Especially with wives and shit. More often there are multiple people's lives and interests intertwined as well as tons of plausible deniability and people rationalizing that something could just be a rumor.

I've been on every side of this situation, I'll admit, and pretty much every single time it gets exposed because of either a guilty party admitting, a suspicious party investigating or someone involved just simply fucking up and blowing the subterfuge. Sometimes crazy shit like an affair getting too attached/crazy and letting the wife/husband know they are going to take the spouse from them. I've never known it to be a matter of "hey bro, I gotta tell you something" followed by a rational assessment of the situation and responsive course of action.

Maybe in HS or college there would be a "dude she's banging that other guy wtf" and even then drama follows despite everyone being immature beer drinking idiots who in retrospect had little to gain or lose in the long run. But for adults there's so much at stake from jobs, marriages, children, friendships between couples/mutual friendships....people manage to rationalize away letting things go on under the radar and hope for the best rather than be involved in the nuclear war that's percolating.

In thisparticularcase, I can't even imagine what you're asking Numbers to do. "Hey, you don't know me but I'm a student here, and I've been banging you're wife for the past year. But I'm totally going to stop now since I found out you're married. Have a good day!" WTF, seriously?
I don't get it, your insinuating that people would be MORE mature in high school than they are in their adult life?
I don't think he needs to tell him that he's a student there, or that he's going to stop, just a "Hey, your wife has been unfaithful to you the past year with me, she just told me this recently and I thought I should bring it to your attention. Any questions?"
It's really not that outlandish. Either way, do it or don't I'm not holding a gun to his head. It's a suggestion and what I'd do given the situation.
 

bixxby

Molten Core Raider
2,750
47
Just nut on her face and send the guy an email with the picture. he'll put it all together.