What If...?

ronne · Aug 24, 2021

Yea not sure where we suddenly got squeamish about him killing people during WW2. It was a war, he carried a gun, he killed a fuckload of people.

j00t · Aug 25, 2021

Grizzlebeard said:
I haven't really read much of the 10 pages so far but I tried watching EP1 last night and switched off halfway through.

Going to sound like a colossal tart here but the violence just seemed too callous for what is supposed to be a superhero story. Watching her just butchering Germans left right and centre, throwing them out of planes, etc. didn't have me punching the air so much as just feeling uncomfortable.

90's action movies are looking down at your weak constitution and laughing in cigar

Gavinmad · Aug 25, 2021

He's not entirely wrong, they very much glossed over the fact that Steve was killing people in Cap 1. Hell he's killing people in all three movies but it's not obvious because the violence is so sanitized and you often have to sit and think 'wait that would have killed him' to realize he was killing people.

meStevo · Aug 25, 2021

To me this one felt a lot more like an issue of the comics.

Qhue · Aug 25, 2021

Yes very much so. I've taken to making sure to not look at the opening credits so as to avoid the names of various actors who will appear. This helps keep things suspenseful.

I'm surprised it took me as long as it did to figure out.

velk · Aug 25, 2021

That ep was surprisingly good.

Gavinmad · Aug 25, 2021

Qhue said:
I'm surprised it took me as long as it did to figure out.

I figured it out right away and I think it's mostly because I read your post before I watched it lol.

Good episode and thankfully lays to rest the theory that the what-if episodes are a single shared universe.

Kaige · Aug 25, 2021

Pretty good episode, although I thought the end result was kinda cheesy.

spronk · Aug 25, 2021

it was a heavy dose of member berries, but i do like that we are seeing alts of characters we just aren't gonna get to see in live action ever again. This is definitely a different timeline than episode 1 though, right? Especially with the ending. I don't remember my MCU history either but i don't think in the movies those characters had their "origin stories" all in the same week.

The bad guy/reveal was a bit weak, and I think Black Widow could have definitely said something A LOT MORE FUCKING USEFUL on the phone but yeah, mostly enjoyed it. I do want more stuff thats wildly different, like episode 2, while I felt episode 1 & 3 were more minor tweaks to the stories we've already seen. Everything with Loki was A+++

Wombat · Aug 25, 2021

Gavinmad said:
thankfully lays to rest the theory that the what-if episodes are a single shared universe.

Does it?
All we really know is:
Coulson is a 'Steve' fanboy.. but Hydra Smasher existed in that timeline.
Hawkeye and Fury were alive when they pulled Captain Carter out of the Shuma Gorath portal... but we don't know when that was relative to the first Thor movie.
Something with a Captain America star is under ice... but they rather pointedly don't show what or who.

Weird that that wasn't Brie Larson, but was Michael Douglas.

Edit: I suppose we also know Wakanda isn't conquered by Asgardians whenever T'Challa comes back. But the intro with the shattering glass _is_ simply clips from the show, and that's clearly Killmonger next to Red Skull @ 1:04 - I can't imagine any episode leftists wouldn't be more dying to make than, say, Klaw leading the Asgardians into Wakanda and Killmonger getting to kill the invading white people (and running the world afterward).

Cybsled · Aug 25, 2021

The whole point of this is to show different multiverses...having everything in one universe makes no fucking sense.

At best, you'd just have crossovers between universes

Gavinmad · Aug 25, 2021

Wombat said:
Something with a Captain America star is under ice... but they rather pointedly don't show what or who.

Except we already saw Peggy and Fury meet in the first episode, she wasn't frozen she was brought forward in time by the space stone and Shuma Gorath. The shield can't be in Peggy's possession, in the Collector's possession, AND frozen in the arctic.

The only way they could make it more clear that they aren't a shared universe is a giant glowing neon sign that spelled it out explicitly before each episode.

meStevo · Aug 25, 2021

My expectation is these are all branches of the branch created by Peggy not leaving the room. Different heroes are assembled from these realities to defeat a living Infinity Gauntlet: Ultron.

The season concludes with these universes ending with some carryover/connections to live action MCU and providing a rough template for season 2.

Randin · Aug 26, 2021

After three episodes, it seems like they're going for an upward trajectory in just how wacky the each successive scenario goes. Assuming they continue on that path, it's gonna be interesting to see just how out there the final episode will be.

j00t · Aug 26, 2021

RE: single universe theory

it's quite clearly NOT a single universe. we've seen clips from an unaired episode of winter soldier (bucky with long hair) but in the captain carter episode, bucky never falls off the train. even if we can't take that into consideration since it hasn't aired yet, the collector has captain america's shield, NOT captain carter's shield. captain america's shield has the star on it, captain carter's shield has the union jack. and thirdly, at the end of THIS episode, we clearly see a frozen captain america shield, which didn't happen in the first episode. like gavinmad pointed out you can't have the same shield be in 3 different places.

you also have the fact that in the first episode, captain carter comes back during the beginning of the avengers movie, but hawkeye is there with him and that obviously couldn't have happened if he died during the first thor movie.

in the beginning of each episode, the watcher narrates what happened in the MCU, and then he shows us what happened in a different universe. there should never be the assumption that he is only comparing 2 different universes.

Qhue · Aug 26, 2021

What If...? Works as a purely episodic affair. It's a perfect little terrarium of character and concept exploration which also allows for maximum fanservice at times.

Alex · Aug 26, 2021

This is my favorite Marvel TV show so far. Animation style is great.

Cybsled · Aug 26, 2021

Randin said:
After three episodes, it seems like they're going for an upward trajectory in just how wacky the each successive scenario goes. Assuming they continue on that path, it's gonna be interesting to see just how out there the final episode will be.

Marvel Zombies is going to be one of them, so I wouldn't be surprised if it were that lol

Mudcrush Durtfeet · Aug 26, 2021

Cybsled said:
Marvel Zombies is going to be one of them, so I wouldn't be surprised if it were that lol

If the show is anything like the comics, the universe is going to get destroyed in at least one episode.

Downhammer · Aug 26, 2021

Mudcrush Durtfeet said:
If the show is anything like the comics, the universe is going to get destroyed in at least one episode.

I thought it was implied that Ep2 resulted in destruction, or at least whatever total domination Ego was hoping for.

What If...?

Nǐ hǎo, yǒu jīn zi ma?

Silver Baronet of the Realm

Mr. Poopybutthole

I think your wife's a bigfoot gus.

Tranny Chaser

Trakanon Raider

Mr. Poopybutthole

<WoW Guild Officer>

FPS noob

Trakanon Raider

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider

Mr. Poopybutthole

I think your wife's a bigfoot gus.

Trakanon Raider

Silver Baronet of the Realm

Tranny Chaser

Still a Music Elitist

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider

Hungry Ogre

Vyemm Raider