World of Warcraft: Current Year
- Thread starter hodj
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,272
- 15,094
moonarchia
The Scientific Shitlord
- 23,430
- 42,589
Brikker
Trump's Staff
- 6,296
- 4,833
Who on Cenarius? I played in Pirate from TBC to WotLK. Guild officially died in WoD I think.
vGrade
Potato del Grande
- 1,755
- 2,735
I remember Pirate. I raided with DE until the better of us broke off and formed Heist
- 1
vGrade
Potato del Grande
- 1,755
- 2,735
Not the same guild
We were that 1 percent who even got the see Naxx 40 man and that pre nerf dance used to make most guilds who did see it quit. Raiders weren't ready back then. 895,000 level 60's on us servers and only 23 guilds cleared Vanilla Naxx. Less than 0.1% players killed Kel'thuzad, a number that has never been achieved with any other dungeon in the history of WOW. Being at the top back then was different than today
Last edited:
a c i d.f l y
ಠ_ಠ
- 20,062
- 99,466
It's always a stupid argument, defending achievements from vanilla, when the fights themselves weren't a challenge, it was all logistics. Congratulations on being able to attune and gather 40 fucks to run at the most basic of mechanics the game hasn't seen since vanilla.
- 1
Burns
Avatar of War Slayer
- 7,439
- 14,654
Heigan was one of my favorite fights in the zone, but its been so long, I dont remember what the nerf was. I remember seeing the fight on the first night the zone was released, but I think we moved over to spider because the other top tier guilds went Deathknight wing first.
Burns
Avatar of War Slayer
- 7,439
- 14,654
A lot of the time requirements outside of raiding were logistics, that they have cut heavily back on through the years, but there was a different kind of challenge (than just mechanics) in vanilla, to a point that vanilla and modern raiding are hardly comparable. A couple of the things I can think of off hand are:
When the final two boss fights of the zone weren't broke, they were tuned to require the raid be in "x" percent of gear from the previous bosses in the zone.
They put in cock blocks like resist fights, that required patterns and drops from the current tier.
Threat and mana management were a mini game all in itself.
You had to get 40 people to do those simple mechanics on much poorer connections than we have now and if you had less than 15 carries, you were doing good.
For officers, managing ~50 raiders for a 40 man raid just made everything that much more difficult.
a c i d.f l y
ಠ_ಠ
- 20,062
- 99,466
Everything you just listed was still logistics. Having a decent gear level or resist isn't a direct challenge, it's a time sink requirement. And even still, the majority of those fights were pure single positioning fights. Group A stands here, group B stands here, spam your two abilities ad nauseum. Maybe have a tank swap, or group a switches positions with group B. But those were standardized. During Maiden in TOS, certain fucks have to switch sides, and also not stand in spirals, and also stand in meteor style hammers, and avoid cross contamination, and... The comparison is laughable. Gear checks, resists checks, and player quantity checks, I'm so glad are more or less set aside (save the 20 person lock on Mythic raiding).
- 1
Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,272
- 15,094
My theory is they wanted either a server they could be server 1st on or wanted a server with a large pool to draw from that isn't malganis
- 1
j00t
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 7,380
- 7,476
i mean, also understand player abilities have drastically changed as well. pally healers had 2 heals. but then we also had to spam blessings on 40 people every 5 minutes. and make sure judgment was up on the boss every 15 seconds or however short it lasted. oh and also decurse. and remember dps had to wait nearly 30 seconds before engaging the boss so the tank could have enough threat on him.
the mechanics were "simpler" but because there was less going on mechanically, a lot of those mechanics were more punishing.
the mechanics were "simpler" but because there was less going on mechanically, a lot of those mechanics were more punishing.
- 6,051
- 6,036
I do -not- miss that shit. At all. Ever.
I don't really think that's a reasonable argument. There are a great number of fights, even in ToS, where a single missed cue is a wipe.
Last edited:
Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,272
- 15,094
I'm sorry but you guys talking about the challenges in vanilla don't know what is actually challenging. Buffing 40 people every 15 minutes isn't a challenge - that's a shitty design choice. Taunt missing isn't a challenge, that's stupid fucking design.
Naxx40 was hard shit - I was there, I know. My neighbor was in one of the guilds from Zuljin that actually even killed KT.
None of what you guys are listing is hard. The heigen dance isn't hard, it's a retard check. Nefarian isn't hard, it was a gear check.
The encounters these days are way more complex. Even finding 20 people capable of mythic is the hardest part of running a guild for me.
Naxx40 was hard shit - I was there, I know. My neighbor was in one of the guilds from Zuljin that actually even killed KT.
None of what you guys are listing is hard. The heigen dance isn't hard, it's a retard check. Nefarian isn't hard, it was a gear check.
The encounters these days are way more complex. Even finding 20 people capable of mythic is the hardest part of running a guild for me.
- 1
- 1
j00t
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 7,380
- 7,476
well, i'm thinking of the whatever fight in naxx where if you didn't cleanse the poison ASAP, the person died. and like, 15 people at a time would get poisoned. it wasn't COMPLEX. you just spammed cleanse. today's fights CLEARLY have a ton more going on, so it's easier to miss a cue. there's 300 spell effects going on so it's easier to stand in the fire just because it all gets lost in the noise.
the point i was making isn't that it was HARDER, it was different.
Penance
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 6,428
- 8,354
The only people deserving of any praise for killing vanilla bosses are the guild leaders and recruitment officers.
There's a thread where you can talk about the glorious poop socking days of farming resists and pretending you had any semblance of skill at video games because your taunt didn't get resisted or you were really good at mashing decursive.
There's a thread where you can talk about the glorious poop socking days of farming resists and pretending you had any semblance of skill at video games because your taunt didn't get resisted or you were really good at mashing decursive.
- 1