Thinking back to when some of us were in our 40 man.. I dont remember us ever, EVER, inviting someone that sucked into the guild to raid MC/BWL/AQ/Nax. So you can push that notion right out the door. If someone kept dying to dumb shit, they would be kicked from the raid in no time. Our problem with 40 man was that it wasnt big enough for us to fit everyone that wanted to raid. If you werent with us from the beginning, and you werent a needed class, you didnt have a guaranteed spot... and I honestly think this is how most guilds that are serious about downing content handled things at that time. Not a hell of a lot different from how my guild is ran right now for Mythic. But that shit doesnt apply to mom and pop guilds and I get that.
Think for a moment back when we played Asherons Call, EverQuest, Ultima Online, or Dark Ages of Camelot and we had a literal FUCK TON of people in our guilds. Drama was there, of course, but to me, the good far outweighed the bad. That streamer points out shit perfectly, in that all those personalities coming together under one guild and still being able to collectively get along and have a good time playing the game together made for some some epic, sometimes funny, sometimes memorable moments. A far cry and away from where it is now, where I know the people in my guild.. but outside of my clique, I dont KNOW those people. Hell, I have a group of friends Ive been playing games with for the last 5 years that I met on Project 1999 and we became friends because of the good times we had with 50-60 people all trying to accomplish something, talking shit and having a good time. The feels man, I got them for 40 man content.