Ashes of Creation
- Thread starter Tearofsoul
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Cinge
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 7,356
- 2,426
Nice non answer and right to defensive/insulting. Oh yeah you are $500 in or more, defend away!
- 1
- 1
- 1
Randin
Trakanon Raider
- 1,933
- 892
So, no clue if this is at all implemented in the current alpha, but I've been curious about this and haven't seen any statement on the matter. What's the game doing with regards to shit like encounter locking and kill-stealing mechanics? After having GW2 be the only MMO that I've touched for some years, it'll be weird going back into a game where you can't just hop into an ongoing fight to lend someone a hand.
Mahes
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 5,642
- 6,944
While that has merit, I could also get my money back if I did not like the system. I could do this for another 70 days. At the moment, I have no intention of doing that because I enjoyed what I played.
- 11,294
- 2,409
Griefing is griefing regardless of the goal of the game. It was griefing back in UO when we would loot people's houses because they were too dumb and carried their house keys on them, it was griefing in AC when we camped Shoji to kill new players as they logged in Darktide and stood no chance or farmed people trying to level up and it was griefing in many other occasions in many other pvp games. It is part of the server/game rules, since it's open pvp, but it's still griefing. They specifically told you to not grief during the alpha to get good testing.
Mind you I'm not saying it's good or bad, there's definitely a segment of mmo players who want this type of game so bad that even shitty games like Archeage or Darkfall or Mortal Online even are getting players, just it seems very disingenuous to try to argue that corpse camping a low lvl/low gear player or something of the sort is somehow not griefing because "it's a pvp server/game". The term emerged specifically from pvp servers/games.
- 1
any so called hardcore pvper who doesn't acknowledge that griefing needs to be mitigated for a game to be a success deserve the most severe ridicule for being an idiot.
- 3
- 1
Ukerric
Bearded Ape
- 8,461
- 10,646
Since we just got reminded this is a full world PvP game, I assume you deal with "locking" by killing the person who engaged the mob, then you end stealing its loot once he's dead.
zzeris
King Turd of Shit Hill
- 21,017
- 91,428
That's some good feedback. This is the kind of stuff I like reading when you know the game is still early. Lots of data and you can see both negatives and positives. I think this game's got the best blend of talent, money, and ideas out of the soon to be available options.
Kirun
Buzzfeed Editor
- 19,690
- 16,109
"Griefing" is too subjective, in my opinion. It's so hard to define, depending on the specific game, rulesets, systems, etc. I agree that it's something that needs some form of "mitigation", but that's also something that has to be done carefully as well. I usually err on the side of letting players police themselves, similar to UO and others, but there are times where devs need to make certain calls.
Cybsled
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 17,307
- 13,843
At a bare minimum for a PVP game, anti-griefing should include
1) Mechanisms to prevent high levels from murdering low levels in lower level areas - preferably with some type of scaling mechanism (ie, very low levels can't be killed in starting areas at all, something that prevents or heavily penalizes high levels from massacring mid-levels in mid-level areas, etc). Bottom feeding kills any PVP game long term because it drives away new players before they can even get to a point where they have a chance to compete.
2) Anti-spawn camping mechanisms - avoid situations where the player is chain killed and can't escape it or has no option but to try to run back to their corpse.
3) Mechanisms that don't let players bypass PVP restrictions or allow them to harass without impunity. For example in Archeage, troll guilds would create roadblocks in areas that had no PVP and as such, left you with very limited options on how to deal with it
1) Mechanisms to prevent high levels from murdering low levels in lower level areas - preferably with some type of scaling mechanism (ie, very low levels can't be killed in starting areas at all, something that prevents or heavily penalizes high levels from massacring mid-levels in mid-level areas, etc). Bottom feeding kills any PVP game long term because it drives away new players before they can even get to a point where they have a chance to compete.
2) Anti-spawn camping mechanisms - avoid situations where the player is chain killed and can't escape it or has no option but to try to run back to their corpse.
3) Mechanisms that don't let players bypass PVP restrictions or allow them to harass without impunity. For example in Archeage, troll guilds would create roadblocks in areas that had no PVP and as such, left you with very limited options on how to deal with it
- 4
The major thing giving me hope here is the asian games usually do have a fairly good solution by making being flagged a PK hard to fix and really painful so it goes a long way towards fixing that imbalance, lineage 2 is a great example and I think Steve takes quite a bit of inspiration from those types of games.
I think EVEs solution is better for guild combat where you can PVE your entire time in the game in areas where PVP really isn't a major threat or you can go into more dangerous territory for better money per hour and prestige, Darkfall kind of had this system in 2.0 but they were way way too conservative with only very limited newb zones being safe and then they made it even shittier by making gathering a global system so even nodes had nothing, you need a system like EVE where 50% of the world or so is somewhat lawful and players can mostly enjoy the game without being prey constantly.
If they go the route of Darkfall or Shadowbane though where being red really didn't negatively impact you very much at all and then let you PK whoever you want in 95% of the world outside a few newb only safe areas then ya, this game will see a catastrophic population crash within 3 months.
Hosix
All labs matter!
- 4,737
- 6,642