Well, as you can see from the picture, they"re not massive fake ones. I find that to be a turn off, personally. At least in terms of a girl I want a relationship with and not just random sex.
There"s no question that I prefer a real set to fake ones. They"re fun to play around with, I guess, but in some respects not so much. They feel nothing like real tits, and she had very little sensitivity with hers. As far as the scars go, she had a good surgeon and I never once saw them until I asked her about them and she showed me.
Personally I"m not much of a boob guy anyway. I actually dislike large natural breasts because they"re almost never decent looking. I"d rather go for a nice perky set of B"s, which is about where the new girl falls.