- 46,372
- 98,475
Doesnt matter considering their vote was irrelevant.Which Republicans were in favor of single-payer?
Doesnt matter considering their vote was irrelevant.Which Republicans were in favor of single-payer?
That's some pretty shitty logic, Big P, but I respect the audacity. In no way are their votes irrelevant. A Republican vote for single-payer is just as good as a Democrat vote. It's not like Republican votes just stop counting the instant the other party obtains a majority, and Republicans don't somehow get to shirk blame for their failure to support correct policies just because their party doesn't have "control" of the Senate/House.Doesnt matter considering their vote was irrelevant.
I think his point was the Dems had a filibuster proof majority in the Senate and controlled the House and passed the Affordable Care Act without a single R vote. If this is the case, they should've just went with single payer if that's what they wanted.That's some pretty shitty logic, Big P, but I respect the audacity. In no way are their votes irrelevant. A Republican vote for single-payer is just as good as a Democrat vote. It's not like Republican votes just stop counting the instant the other party obtains a majority, and Republicans don't somehow get to shirk blame for their failure to support correct policies just because their party doesn't have "control" of the Senate/House.
Don't forget that they didn't have a majority in the Senate while Al Franken's win was being challenged for months on end by his republican challenger. Then shortly after he took his seat, Kennedy died and they lost the majority again until someone was appointed to his seat for the interim and was able to vote on passing the Senate version of the bill that was negotiated with members of the GOP on Max Bauchus' committee. Bauchus refused to invite single payer proponents to the table so it was never going to happen. Then Scott Brown won Kennedy's old seat at which point everyone thought that the ACA was dead. Some parliamentary manoeuvres later and we have the ACA.I think his point was the Dems had a filibuster proof majority in the Senate and controlled the House and passed the Affordable Care Act without a single R vote. If this is the case, they should've just went with single payer if that's what they wanted.
You have just discovered the GOP voting base (and a part of the far left as well)completely idiotic.
So ademocratsenator fucked everything up? Got it.Don't forget that they didn't have a majority in the Senate while Al Franken's win was being challenged for months on end by his republican challenger. Then shortly after he took his seat, Kennedy died and they lost the majority again until someone was appointed to his seat for the interim and was able to vote on passing the Senate version of the bill that was negotiated with members of the GOP on Max Bauchus' committee. Bauchus refused to invite single payer proponents to the table so it was never going to happen. Then Scott Brown won Kennedy's old seat at which point everyone thought that the ACA was dead. Some parliamentary manoeuvres later and we have the ACA.
No, one democrat senator AND a shitload of republican senators "fucked everything up."So ademocratsenator fucked everything up? Got it.
Something like 4 republicans voted for it technically - it gets buried by most media though, but if you look at the votes on the Congressional website its there clear as day.Doesnt matter considering their vote was irrelevant.
citation needed, only person you could consider was the lady on the senate committee to bring the bill to a vote.Something like 4 republicans voted for it technically - it gets buried by most media though, but if you look at the votes on the Congressional website its there clear as day.
The bill then passed by a vote of 60-39 on December 24, 2009, with all Democrats and two independents voting for, and all Republicans voting against (except for Jim Bunning, who did not vote).
The House passed the Senate bill with a 219-212 vote on March 21, 2010, with 34 Democrats and all 178 Republicans voting against it.
I've got a conservative friend that thinks the entire rest of the world lies about their stats.The old way wasn't working. Comparing our quality of health care to the rest of the developed world should prove that to anyone with a functioning brain.
But but we have way more people than each of those other countries! There's no way their system could work here, it won't scale! Plus, those countries don't have American Inventors!I've got a conservative friend that thinks the entire rest of the world lies about their stats.