Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,376
- 16,293
Ample warning, completely broken link. I see no issue with it. You have to work just to see someone die
Making a Murderer (Netflix) - New info
- Thread starter Adebisi
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Ambiturner
Ssraeszha Raider
- 16,079
- 19,631
Yes. As far as I know they only put that together because of BD's "confession" along with the haircut they apparently gave her.
Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,376
- 16,293
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
edit: I just clued in to what you meant.... I'm a doorknob. All good, Noodlemod
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
In one of his stories, yes. In another she was only killed in the garage and stabbed in the chest/stomach
- 3,822
- 4,366
I'm good with 100%. But if it makes you feel better by saying 99.99% then fine. Yes, there is that off chance that jesus descended from heaven and cleaned up the evidence of the murder/rape from those locations, waved a magic wand and made it like it never happened. Hell maybe the dude is a muslim and Mohammed came down from heaven, helped him rape her? I guess it's possible. If you wanna hold out on that 0.01% feel free.
But the reason I made the post can be clearly seen not 2 posts later. This thread is literally the same arguments back and forth since like page 12. The dust settles, we finally arrive at the point of enlightenment, and someone new finishes watching the documentary and is all like, "did you see this clickbait article written by the prosecutor? omg he's guilty here's some other bullshit that I made up" and the cycle starts over again.
But the reason I made the post can be clearly seen not 2 posts later. This thread is literally the same arguments back and forth since like page 12. The dust settles, we finally arrive at the point of enlightenment, and someone new finishes watching the documentary and is all like, "did you see this clickbait article written by the prosecutor? omg he's guilty here's some other bullshit that I made up" and the cycle starts over again.
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
Well here's an idea: Start posting about the things you want to talk about or get out
Noodleface
A Mod Real Quick
- 38,376
- 16,293
Cad
scientia potentia est
- 25,871
- 50,878
We are all familiar with the blood SA supposedly left on the ignition of Teresa's vehicle right? And that he had a cut on his finger so this is plausible?
Trollolol, the cut is on his left hand middle finger. Get in your cars tonight and just TRY to rub your left hand middle finger on the ignition on the right side of the steering wheel.
Trollolol, the cut is on his left hand middle finger. Get in your cars tonight and just TRY to rub your left hand middle finger on the ignition on the right side of the steering wheel.
Cad
scientia potentia est
- 25,871
- 50,878
Thats after they removed the snowmobile and the mountain of shit that was piled on top of it, IIRC
- 3,389
- 141
I don't think there is a single person here saying this. Everyone, literally everyone understands he got assfucked by the system. Everyone also understands thats by far the most compelling, and devastating part of the documentary. Some people just think there's a possibility that all that is true while he also could have killed her.
Ambiturner
Ssraeszha Raider
- 16,079
- 19,631
Have you ever seen a forum thread before? You actually think there's going to be a point where everyone just agrees 100% on everything and they lock the thread down?
Wtf is wrong with you?
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
I think most of us were on board with the blood being planted.
Wait.... isn't that his right hand though??
Edit: It's totally his right hand, man. I don't think that hurts the case for planted blood evidence though.
But to be honest, it looks to be in the right spot to leave blood on that part of the dash (Right hand, middle finger, outer side... mimmic turning a key)... there's even two wipes from the turning the ignition, then returning to the resting position...
But again, I don't think that changes anything though.
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
Chukzombi
Millie's Staff Member
- 73,146
- 214,433
Jive Turkey
Karen
- 6,740
- 9,159
Stabbed in the chest and stomach was one of the scenarios.
Or do you mean cut up, as in dismembered? Even apart from anything to do with the trial, why would you think a dead person's arteries would spray?
- 3,389
- 141
None of the story really matters (in the sense of what actually happened, obviously it matters in the legal sense). There's a reason they didn't even touch the BD confession in Stephen's trial. Any details just muddled the prosecution's case. Kratz doesn't even mention the flip from bedroom kill scene to garage until his closing arguments.
Obviously nothing happened in the trailer and it seems very unlikely (to the point where I think you can probably give the same level of certainty) that nothing happened in the garage other than perhaps the RAV4 being parked in it with her body in the trunk.
At that point you have to take that complete lack of evidence and weigh two different scenarios. Either Avery did it elsewhere on the property, and cleaned it up and/or the cops just didn't care to search after "obtaining" the other evidence in the case. Or the murder happened off the property by someone else entirely and her remains and car were then planted on Avery either by that person or the cops.
Both of those scenarios have tons of unanswered questions, obviously. I just still think its possible either one of them could have happened. The documentary, while doing an excellent job of showing the potential corruption, paints SA as genuine, warm, caring and most importantly completely innocent. Now you guys might argue they do that because there's no evidence to show him otherwise, but I disagree and it's my only issue with the documentary. It's done intentionally because it's easier to sympathize with someone that's innocent.
If you watch a series like The Staircase, you can see the filmmakers take a completely impartial stance and for a documentary that just makes more sense to me.
Obviously nothing happened in the trailer and it seems very unlikely (to the point where I think you can probably give the same level of certainty) that nothing happened in the garage other than perhaps the RAV4 being parked in it with her body in the trunk.
At that point you have to take that complete lack of evidence and weigh two different scenarios. Either Avery did it elsewhere on the property, and cleaned it up and/or the cops just didn't care to search after "obtaining" the other evidence in the case. Or the murder happened off the property by someone else entirely and her remains and car were then planted on Avery either by that person or the cops.
Both of those scenarios have tons of unanswered questions, obviously. I just still think its possible either one of them could have happened. The documentary, while doing an excellent job of showing the potential corruption, paints SA as genuine, warm, caring and most importantly completely innocent. Now you guys might argue they do that because there's no evidence to show him otherwise, but I disagree and it's my only issue with the documentary. It's done intentionally because it's easier to sympathize with someone that's innocent.
If you watch a series like The Staircase, you can see the filmmakers take a completely impartial stance and for a documentary that just makes more sense to me.