I'm sorry, man. This makes me sad. Not all marriages are equal, and I would recommend marriage to everyone. I'm not trying to be a dick, nor say my life is better than yours, I merely see such a huge advantage to having a life partner that I can't set that aside to see the negatives. I know I'm lucky and all that. But there are really good things about being married, too.
There's nothing practical about love.
And it can fade. And it takes 2 people dedicated to trying to prevent it from doing so. And even then it takes luck. End of the day there's nothing practical about marriage. But end of the day, you meet the right woman, and you'll want to be married to her all the same. I wouldn't believe it either if I'd never met a woman that did that to me. It seems to be a rare thing.
Big Phoenix
Frenzied Wombat
I personally think that you both look at marriage a little too much from a legal (Big P) or macro (FW) standpoint that encompasses the issues of when marriage goes wrong. I agree with parts of what both of you say, but I quoted the two above because they are examples (along with, I think, me and my wife) of good choices during the part of dating where most people make the biggest mistake when they look for a partner:
selection.
Marriage is the absolute hardest thing you can do in the modern world. It is taking a being that has been taught to fend for itself for its entire life and having them voluntarily share everything in their life with someone else. I know that some people will say raising kids is harder than marriage but raising kids comes with so many small rewards as they develop that there is always some new sense of accomplishment that makes you think 'this was worth all the sacrifice.' Not so with marriage. There can be very long stretches of time (hello pregnancy!) where neither of you can get on the same page and it takes monumental effort to get back to civility. There are no little biological dopamine rewards for being the bigger person and ending a fight with your spose especially when it means that you still have more work to do if you want things to go from just civil back to some level of serene living...… until the next minor blowup sends you both right back down to the gladiator pit.
For the past 30 years or so (to sort of quote King of the Hill) our society has had a lot of quit in it. We look for hot girls (or guys) that are spontaneous, go with the flow, live in the moment, YOLO, follow your dreams, but most of all
BE HAPPY. We are told that when the going gets tough that divorce is easier because
you deserve to be happy. Fuck that. Happiness is a fleeting emotion that can soar high or dip low from hour to hour in a life that lasts something around 613 thousand hours in total. True dating in this day and age should be talking realistically about and planning for the actual future. It seems unsexy because it is; but sexual attraction, hot bodies, and that desire to be around someone every single minute of every day fades. Once that happens you are left with the true person and if you do not get along with them then you won't be able to experience the two real emotions that are stable and long lasting: satisfaction and contentment.
I don't answer people anymore when they ask me if I'm happy because, like I said above, I think happiness is a misleading barometer in life. I can tell you that after 9 years of marriage and 3 young children that I could not be more satisfied with my choice for a mate and I'm pretty sure she would say the same thing. That leads us to be content with our life but never so content that we stop trying to be better for ourselves, our children, and each other because the real killer in a relationship is the complacency that leads people to say 'but our relationship was
so easy, we were always
so happy together.'
I'm reading this back and it sounds like I'm lecturing, but I promise that I am not. My parents were divorced by the time I was 10 and neither one of them ever gave me or my brother any advice on what to look for in a relationship. I got lucky before meeting my eventual wife that I had some relationships that showed how short sighted it could be to not plan for the future and, even then, once I got married it was rocky because we both thought that we were making each other happy and that was enough. I just wanted to give you a little insight into someone that agrees with your views on the problem of marriage as an institution but disagrees that the best way forward is to not marry or treat your marriage partner like an adversary from the get go.