I don't get the negativity... sure, I was mad about no pre-download and the server instability. I was ready for it though, EA teamed up with the realistic state of online gaming management just allowed me to shrug it off (not sure if you guys seen the article regarding MMO'ers talking about the SimCity release).
Anyway, the game looks pretty good. The screenshots don't do it justice. There's a lot of decision making involved in the game. Meaning it's not all about making squares and putting down whatever you want. To be "successful" you have to take into consideration long term planning. You have to consider how much everything will impact your hourly/monthly budget, if you play with friends divide up services, and be map/mineral aware to make the most of your specialization and industry.
The amazon pundits are ridiculous, i'm sick of everyone complaining about DRM. It's absolutely ignorant, I get it but you can't complain IF YOU BUY THE GAME. Boycott it or whatever.
Overall, the game is fun with friends, I do not like that water is finite and space is limited more so than I would like but, it's actually a great sequel. It's not a complete miss and they could easily fix the actual problems of the game itself and I think they will.
On an other note, the school I teach at participates in the "Future City" competition and will be taking part in SimCityEDU next year and integrating SimCity into our business program as a business simulation along with thousands of other schools this coming year.