The Expanse

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Kirun

Buzzfeed Editor
19,515
15,898
My one complaint about the show is that they keep adding random shit in and changing book events. I can't stand it when shows/movies do this. Don't get me wrong, sometimes the producers/directors have time/money constraints and have to cut certain things out. Sometimes they even need to combine characters or summarize events to simply very complex situations. I don't like those things, but I understand them. What I donotunderstand is when some asswipe studio exec or aspiring screen writer decides thattheyknow better than the author of the books how the story should unfold and adds random shit in just to "spice things up."

I know I'm showing my nerd on this one, but they did that shit in LoTR Two Towers at the battle of Helms Deep. First, they cut out a bunch of important stuff which, like I said, I understand. But then they randomly have Haldir show up with a couple hundred elven archers that never happened in the book-- just to die almost immediately and unceremoniously as if to say "I know those guys weren't supposed to be there, so we'll just go ahead and kill them off like the mistake they were."
I'm not a fan of stuff being "added" either, especially since it usually comes at a cost of other things being cut out, but I really enjoyed the character development Amos got in this episode. He's quickly becoming my favorite.
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
What I donotunderstand is when some asswipe studio exec or aspiring screen writer decides thattheyknow better than the author of the books how the story should unfold and adds random shit in just to "spice things up."
Well, in this case (per Ty Frank and Daniel Abraham's own twitters), the authors themselves decided to add that stuff so that the book readers have new stories they didn't knew to watch.

Also, somepromo photos for ep 9. Given how they re-order and rewrite stuff, can't figure out if we do have Julie there or if it's flashbacks from her arrival at Eros. Still assuming the latter.

But at last, we know when Miller finally meets the Rocinante crew (6th photo, looks like Amos in the back aiming at Miller).
 

Arden

Blackwing Lair Raider
2,793
2,103
Well, in this case (per Ty Frank and Daniel Abraham's own twitters), the authors themselves decided to add that stuff so that the book readers have new stories they didn't knew to watch.
I was wondering if that was the case- if it is it's much more forgivable. I may not like the added stuff, but at least the original creators are the ones adding it in. I have a hard time believing that all the changes are the authors' doing, though. Some changes totally undermine things in the books. I'll still watch it either way.
 

khalid

Unelected Mod
14,071
6,775
This is a good example of why you shouldn't freshly read a book series before watching the tv adaption. You are biasing yourself to feel changes are out of place, even when a new viewer might not see it that way. You can't help but go "wtf, where did that come from" even when to a new viewer it might seem natural.
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
I have a hard time believing that all the changes are the authors' doing, though.
No idea, but both are producers on the show, and they're apparently quite often on site for the shootings and all that, so they are extremely involved.
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
This is a good example of why you shouldn't freshly read a book series before watching the tv adaption.
Yea. I've been reading the series for 5 years (since the first came out in 2010), so it's not too fresh. But did re-read the first three volumes when the first eps landed, to refresh my memories, which might have been a mistake.

Side note for reference: We're currently at page 223 out of 560 (that's when Miller gets on the Ceres-Eros shuttle, which is the last scene of ep 7).
 

Jorren

Maximum Derek
<Bronze Donator>
1,429
1,337
I forget from the books. Did the thing with the hat happen like in this episode?
 

Leadsalad

Cis-XYite-Nationalist
6,226
12,988
I'd completely forgotten the first book. I like some of the little things they've done like the flashback for Fred to Anderson station.
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
I forget from the books. Did the thing with the hat happen like in this episode?
On the Ceres-Eros shuttle, he was next to a priest going to an episcopal conference on Eros, and they talked and that made him internalize that he wasn't coming back to Ceres. But that probably wouldn't work well in the show, so they went with the "let's leave the hat" symbol instead, to mark the end of his life on Ceres.

He still has the hat on Eros in the books. That's how Amos describes him to Holden when he spots him trailing the Roci crew: "blah blah... Goofy hat." (ref: page 232, just checked)
 

Jorren

Maximum Derek
<Bronze Donator>
1,429
1,337
Ah thought as much. I suspect he will get it (or another) back. It is too much a part of his image. Then again Naomi's hair is a part of her life and that seems to be out the window with casting and her hair.
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
episode 8 airs tonight, episode 9 & 10 air back to back next week
Sounds a bit logical, ep 8 should be Holden & crew figuring out stuff about on the Anubis, then heading to Eros and colliding with Miller, while the last 2 are all about the fall of Eros.
I wouldn't be surprised if the last scene of season 1 was Miller & Holden in front of a locked airlock where the Rocinante was supposed to be.
 

LachiusTZ

Rogue Deathwalker Box
<Silver Donator>
14,472
27,162
Wasn't there supposed to be a major reveal in 7? Someone referenced it a few pages back.
 

Xexx

Vyemm Raider
7,790
1,833
So someone created something they cannot control/contain and Mao chick fled with it and now its likely attached to that probe they sent aboard the Anubis and its going to spread quicker than a virgin on her honeymoon aboard Eros?
 

Ukerric

Bearded Ape
<Silver Donator>
8,401
10,486
So someone created something they cannot control/contain and Mao chick fled with it and now its likely attached to that probe they sent aboard the Anubis and its going to spread quicker than a virgin on her honeymoon aboard Eros?
Spoilage from books
They didn't create it. They found it inactive on Saturn's moon Phoebe - the Phoebe station that was obsessing the Martians guy on the Donnager. But that's going to be a major plot point for season 2 now (the origin of the protomolecule) rather than season 1.
 

TJT

Mr. Poopybutthole
<Gold Donor>
43,286
111,151
Never read the books so I'm really enjoying this show. A sci fi show with actual plot complexity and an interesting mystery! I dig it.
 

kaid

Blackwing Lair Raider
4,647
1,187
well they found it on phoebe but they also made some of what they saw on the anubis as they were trying to engineer it into some more usable form and yes monkies playing with hand guns expectedly bad things happened and worse to come