The Girls Who Broke Your Heart Thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

McCheese

SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
6,922
4,327
I never understood guys who put up with unstable women who act like that. I don't know the answer because I've never dealt with it, but I imagine it's something like (1)staying calm and (2)absolutely never putting up with it (ie tell them why you're leaving and just go home). When people have tried to pass some ridiculous accusations at me or are being unreasonable, I always say that we both know they are being unreasonable and that I feel insulted they would think they can pull that shit with me.

If you engage emotionally you automatically lose. And if you repeatedly date women like that, you should look at why you are attracting that kind of woman.
Everything you said is wrong and doesn't work when dealing with the crazy. Like you said, you've never dealt with it.

Wombat is on point with his assertion that emotion is, ironically, the best way to deal with it.

And in actuality, engaging them emotionally works better than engaging them logically. Logic really seems to piss them off and these fights historically come to an end when they finally push me to the brink and I rage, at which point they cry and say they're sorry and want to make up.
And then the awesome crazy make up sex happens, which is the one shining beacon of light when dealing with the crazy.
 

Frenzied Wombat

Potato del Grande
14,730
31,803
And then the awesome crazy make up sex happens, which is the one shining beacon of light when dealing with the crazy.
I'd really like to know the psychological explanation for this actually. After a "crazy" fight, the last thing I want to do is fuck-- I want to go play League of Legends or something and blow off steam. Saying "I'm sorry" doesn't instantly erase the hours/days of anger and frustration I've just been put through. I'm pissed off and the last thing I feel is attraction. How chicks can be shrieking and calling you an asshole one minute, then wanting to fuck your brains out the next and saying I love you I just don't understand.
 

Famm

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
11,041
794
I bet every one of those chicks comes from broken marriages, single mothers, daddy issues, raised by grandparents, etc. Many of them likely worse, like prior child sexual abuse.

You talk about vetting girls, that's one of the most important things, if not the biggest thing, to find out. What was their upbringing and what is their parents' current status and what is their relationship with both parents like as an adult?

Unless you just want to fuck them, the crazy ones are best at that anyway.
 

Dabamf_sl

shitlord
1,472
0
Sorry, you either haven't dated much, live in female Nirvana, or have an amazing ability to vet a woman's behavior-- both present and future. To somehow have gotten this far in life without ever dating an irrational overly-emotional chick is honestly an accomplishment. I'm not in all honesty doubting you, because if you had dated one of these chicks, you would know that using calm logic like "you are being unreasonable" is like throwing kerosene on the fire.

And in actuality, engaging them emotionally works better than engaging them logically. Logic really seems to piss them off and these fights historically come to an end when they finally push me to the brink and I rage, at which point they cry and say they're sorry and want to make up.

I won't dispute that I potentially attract crazies though, but I do think that statistically there are more crazy chicks out there than sane.
Yea as I said I don't have experience with them so I don't know - just sayin that's how I deal with that on the rare occasion someone (not a crazy gf) is acting like that. The girls I've dated tend to fit a certain category and are either not prone to wild emotional swings or just keep it to themselves.
 

Salshun_sl

shitlord
1,003
0
Like a few days ago the GF goes into a rampage because I mention going back to a restaurant we had gone to a few months ago. She insists we've never been there. I say she's wrong, we have, and even remind her what she ordered. She looks up the restaurant on her phone and says she doesn't recognize it and "I must be confusing her with some other girl I took". I sigh and tell her I'll take her there tomorrow and prove it to her, mentioning the dessert we had. She suddenly remembers saying "Oh yeah, that's the place you made me feel fat asshole" and then escalates the fight to shouting levels saying I was "pompously" trying to prove her wrong by saying I would taker her back AND continues to harp on how shitty I made her feel that night at the restaurant THREE MONTHS AGO. Any mention of "why the fuck are we arguing about something that is ancient history" is just like adding fuel to the fire.
Ugh, that shit is the worse. In your case you were in the right, but I've been on the losing end of that shit. More than once I've gone off on a 2 minute story about "remember the time" then bring up some awesome super happy moment, then I get "that wasn't me". I dwell on it for a second, and fuck she's right. Then I want to hide like a turtle or throw myself out of a window. Their is no way of saving yourself in that one.
 

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,717
16,169
Wombat, no one seems to be addressing your question. Where are you meeting these girls? How old are you and how old are they?

PS I always wanna fuck after a good fight.
 

Antarius

Lord Nagafen Raider
1,828
15
I bet every one of those chicks comes from broken marriages, single mothers, daddy issues, raised by grandparents, etc. Many of them likely worse, like prior child sexual abuse.

You talk about vetting girls, that's one of the most important things, if not the biggest thing, to find out. What was their upbringing and what is their parents' current status and what is their relationship with both parents like as an adult?

Unless you just want to fuck them, the crazy ones are best at that anyway.
P.S. been dating a girl for 3 months now, we've (I've) been exclusive for a month. I told her last night that I love her.
 

Izo

Tranny Chaser
19,677
24,073
I broke my longest-ever dry spell. hurray
Did he enjoy it as well?
rrr_img_26620.jpg
 

Palum

what Suineg set it to
27,752
44,473
Soooo, huh. No one's posted anything for awhile so I might as well ramble a bit.

Went out with this chick on Friday, pretty cool and cute to boot. She was 'retail outgoing', IE she could talk about anything but herself. She was obviously very shy/reserved/nervous so I guess I wasn't surprised when she dodged the goodnight kiss, but says she wants to go out again. Send her a text later to make sure she got home safely (fuck you, seemed like the thing to do after another drink) and she apologized for being awkward but said she had a good time. So I made a joke about how I'll simply add a kiss to her tab for next time.

At this point she says with 'Oh, so you say but I never had any interest in pursuing it further!
tongue.png
I honestly thought you were just enjoying my company!'
So I made the best of that unholy bear trap and responded 'I did, those things aren't mutually exclusive you know.'

So yea, probably fucked with that one but this afternoon I sent her a link to a youtube video I had promised to send her yesterday anyway and we chatted a bit. So in said conversation I told her I needed to hit the range now that all the preppers had finished buying ammo and said she should come (because I'm stupid, maybe?). To which she said yes, except she didn't know her schedule next weekend yet but would let me know ("for sure"). I don't mind the shy/awkward thing but I'm not going to do the "let's 'friend' date and hang out for 8 months until maybe you want something else". So we'll see, I guess.

Which brings me to this next point, in that before that conversation today, I decided to ask this other chick out. I didn't initially because she didn't seem my type (very proper and polite conversation) but I kind of warmed up to the idea that she wasn't a complete prude after a few more exchanges. Year older, not as cute but much more outgoing (figure skater and shit). That'll be some evening this week when we can figure out a time.

Dating two chicks at the same time has never ended well for me. Usually just a time thing, where I am slightly more interested in one so I 'ignore' the other a bit too much only to submarine the first choice anyway. So now I'm wondering if I should simply preempt myself and assume that chick 1 is a lost cause for one text which could have been an awkward or shitty joke and bag the one that means business or try and walk the line again.

Blargh.

tongue.png
 

Lusiphur

Peasant
595
47
Soooo, huh. No one's posted anything for awhile so I might as well ramble a bit.

Went out with this chick on Friday, pretty cool and cute to boot. She was 'retail outgoing', IE she could talk about anything but herself. She was obviously very shy/reserved/nervous so I guess I wasn't surprised when she dodged the goodnight kiss, but says she wants to go out again. Send her a text later to make sure she got home safely (fuck you, seemed like the thing to do after another drink) and she apologized for being awkward but said she had a good time. So I made a joke about how I'll simply add a kiss to her tab for next time.

At this point she says with 'Oh, so you say but I never had any interest in pursuing it further!
tongue.png
I honestly thought you were just enjoying my company!'
So I made the best of that unholy bear trap and responded 'I did, those things aren't mutually exclusive you know.'

So yea, probably fucked with that one but this afternoon I sent her a link to a youtube video I had promised to send her yesterday anyway and we chatted a bit. So in said conversation I told her I needed to hit the range now that all the preppers had finished buying ammo and said she should come (because I'm stupid, maybe?). To which she said yes, except she didn't know her schedule next weekend yet but would let me know ("for sure"). I don't mind the shy/awkward thing but I'm not going to do the "let's 'friend' date and hang out for 8 months until maybe you want something else". So we'll see, I guess.

Which brings me to this next point, in that before that conversation today, I decided to ask this other chick out. I didn't initially because she didn't seem my type (very proper and polite conversation) but I kind of warmed up to the idea that she wasn't a complete prude after a few more exchanges. Year older, not as cute but much more outgoing (figure skater and shit). That'll be some evening this week when we can figure out a time.

Dating two chicks at the same time has never ended well for me. Usually just a time thing, where I am slightly more interested in one so I 'ignore' the other a bit too much only to submarine the first choice anyway. So now I'm wondering if I should simply preempt myself and assume that chick 1 is a lost cause for one text which could have been an awkward or shitty joke and bag the one that means business or try and walk the line again.

Blargh.
You are toast with the first one. You have come across as too keen I would think. Focus on number two and then see what else is out there if that doesn't work out.

tongue.png
 

Dabamf_sl

shitlord
1,472
0
Soooo, huh. No one's posted anything for awhile so I might as well ramble a bit.

Went out with this chick on Friday, pretty cool and cute to boot. She was 'retail outgoing', IE she could talk about anything but herself. She was obviously very shy/reserved/nervous so I guess I wasn't surprised when she dodged the goodnight kiss, but says she wants to go out again. Send her a text later to make sure she got home safely (fuck you, seemed like the thing to do after another drink) and she apologized for being awkward but said she had a good time. So I made a joke about how I'll simply add a kiss to her tab for next time.

At this point she says with 'Oh, so you say but I never had any interest in pursuing it further!
tongue.png
I honestly thought you were just enjoying my company!'
So I made the best of that unholy bear trap and responded 'I did, those things aren't mutually exclusive you know.'

So yea, probably fucked with that one but this afternoon I sent her a link to a youtube video I had promised to send her yesterday anyway and we chatted a bit. So in said conversation I told her I needed to hit the range now that all the preppers had finished buying ammo and said she should come (because I'm stupid, maybe?). To which she said yes, except she didn't know her schedule next weekend yet but would let me know ("for sure"). I don't mind the shy/awkward thing but I'm not going to do the "let's 'friend' date and hang out for 8 months until maybe you want something else". So we'll see, I guess.

Which brings me to this next point, in that before that conversation today, I decided to ask this other chick out. I didn't initially because she didn't seem my type (very proper and polite conversation) but I kind of warmed up to the idea that she wasn't a complete prude after a few more exchanges. Year older, not as cute but much more outgoing (figure skater and shit). That'll be some evening this week when we can figure out a time.

Dating two chicks at the same time has never ended well for me. Usually just a time thing, where I am slightly more interested in one so I 'ignore' the other a bit too much only to submarine the first choice anyway. So now I'm wondering if I should simply preempt myself and assume that chick 1 is a lost cause for one text which could have been an awkward or shitty joke and bag the one that means business or try and walk the line again.

Blargh.
sounds like you dodged that landmine as best you could, though I'm not a fan of announcing physical advances in the first place.

She sounds like a suspicious girl. They're the worst because they're too dense to realize that if you were just out to get laid, they'd be the last one you'd go after because you can smell that suspicion from a mile away. Anyway it might be worth another date just to see what happens

tongue.png
 

Johnny53

Vyemm Raider
5,154
1,471
it's not the same...the pic just reminded me of having sex in my truck with my hooker/girlfriend....by the way ex-junkie now