The Girls Who Broke Your Heart Thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Srathor

Vyemm Raider
1,884
3,045
Johnny the thing I do not get is. why not white knight for your wife? I mean she has a shitty home life where her husband is cheating on her and bringing home the drips. Stand up for her dude. Show that cheating insensitive bastard what a real good man is like.
 

iannis

Musty Nester
31,351
17,657
The breakup was in December. I was talking about marriage with her in that thread early last year.

It's been over two months, and yeah, it still fucking sucks. I just can't let it bother me anymore. No fucking closure...not a chance to talk, ask questions, nothing. Completely ignored. She wouldn't even answer any questions I had. The sad thing is I'm also friends with some of her friends, and I hear shit about her. She's not dating, she doesn't do shit...she wasn't doing shit before I found her, either, she was single for _six_ fucking years, because she moves around constantly. Anyway, not gonna get into all those details.
This is actually something that Dabamf would be very good at. There are personality attributes based on childhood attachment to parents. Maybe he'll swoop in here and correct me (which would be fine, because this is stuff that I misremember poorly), but it sounds like she might have some of the traits of a avoidant attachment. You'll never get closure out of this type of person. It's not even that they're trying to be cruel, or disdainful -- it's just not how theythink.

I mean it sounds like astrology, but it's not really. Individuals themselves cannot be quantified -- but groups of them can be studied and bonding patterns do emerge. And then you have to make up silly sounding words to express those patterns with.

It may not be the case, it probably isn't.I mention it because I had a girl like this and it nagged at me for over a year, and I'm pretty sure it was the case for me (as sure as you can be without eliciting the confession of her psychiatrist under torture). But it seems to me that lacking closure, the next best thing is intellectual comprehension. She might have really liked you, and it spooked her down to her very fucking soul. If that happened there's not a fucking thing you can do about it. Or I might be completely full of shit and she's just a cold bitch who just decided she didn't like you that much to begin with -- and again, there's nothing you can do about it. It's really just a different way to say, "Bitch be crazy"... but the process of examining the specifics is just somehow more emotionally satisfying. I suppose that it's because it allows you to say, in hindsight and perhaps wrongly and only for your own pride, "Well... that was doomed to begin with."

But that's still better than nothing.
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,945
7,732
Thanks for the words. It's an interesting read.

I'll give you some more breakdown on this chick without getting into a ton of specifics. She was really special to me because she was European from a country I really love, I know some of the language...it was so unique finding her here because it's pretty much unheard of, as this is not a huge metropolitan area. She really was one in a million in that regard.

I've went over this with friends and girl friends up and down...they've sort of told me the same thing. It's usually men who fear commitment and getting close to someone, but she's a female and had all the tell-tale signs.

She's 40 years old...she has an ex-pat family who has moved all around the world her entire life. Her parents, who used to work for the government of said country, moved every few years (her dad was a diplomat.) She's lived in the U.S. most of her life. She's never been married, has no kids, but she's been engaged twice, and was once in a 7 year relationship, her longest. In the past 10 years, she's been with me and one other dude...the last dude only lasted 9 months, long distance, she said they were only together like a month in reality.

She's really quite nice looking...looks way younger than her age...and has only had two boyfriends in the past 10 years. That's sort of a red flag in itself.

Here's another huuuuuuuuuuge thing. She's up her parent's ASS. Like mad. She lost her last good job...she's been living with them again. They're quite reasonably wealthy and her dad's grandfather is a reasonably famous impressionist artist. Someone told me she's codependent...so I looked up the symptoms of codependency...holy FUCK if she didn't match every single last one.

There were some WTF moments I had with her, and I realized after reading some of this shit, it all jived.

Symptoms of Codependency | Psych Central

Low self esteem...she would think the WORST of anything I said to her sometimes. Like, even if it was good, she'd take it the wrong way. I can't think of a ton of examples, but it happened more than once, and here's one. After she first met my parents (who loved her,) I said to her one day "So, my mom said something about you last night." Her response instantly was "Oh, she thinks I'm too old for you, doesn't she?" I was like "Um, no, she'd never say that...she said you were really sweet and she enjoyed dinner with you."

People pleasing...out the ass as well. I saw her do where she worked...won't get into more details, but it was there.

Reactivity...goes along a lot with things I'd say and she'd give weird responses to.

Caretaking...with her parents? Jesus christ. She cooked, cleaned, took care of the cars, washed their cars, watered the hundred plants a day in the big ass house they had, cleaned all the dishes at night after the big ass dinners they always had, etcetera. I could go on and on.

Control...some details like time ALWAYS had to be her way. I frequently picked activities we did, but time? Fucking forget it. She hardly had any, despite working part time after losing her full time job. This was a big thing when I know I made her sad once...because I said I needed a bit more time a week than she was giving.

Get this shit...we live 20 minutes away. I work a full time job, I go to the gym, the park, I have shit to do. She lost her career...she's working part time as a WAITRESS. She was working 16 goddamn hours a week. Some weeks I saw her 0 to 3 hours a week...OCCASIONALLY she would spend time at my house, and occasionally we went on a weekend getaway, and RARELY I slept at her house...our "date nights" were strictly Wednesday and Saturday...NO DEVIATION. That was the days. She played tennis like 30 fucking hours a week...and some Saturdays I couldn't see her...WHY? Because her dad is involved in the golf and country club they live in...and, by her terminology, she would actually say this to me: "Dad is making me go to (insert event here) to take pictures." This is a fucking 40 year old woman, mind you. Who says her dad is MAKING her go somewhere. Oh...and she has a 4 year degree from a respected university. As stated, she's 40 years old...guess what the longest job she's ever had is? FOUR YEARS. She doesn't commit to shit.

And about her dad...he was nice to me...but holy hell is emotionally abusive to his wife. He would snap and yell at her WHILE I WAS THERE at their house eating dinner...and she did nothing to provoke it. They did this very early on in my knowing them, he had no shame in yelling at her. Mind you this was in another language most of the time, so I didn't catch most of it...sometimes I didn't even realize they were at each other so much, then my girlfriend would tell me later "I know you didn't understand everything, but my parents were arguing the entire night."

Back to that list of codependency...

Dysfunctional communication...holy mother of god this might be #1. She was impossible to talk to in person. She'd clam up...she actually told me once that she better communicates feelings and deep things in text rather than in person. This all ties into her breaking up with me via e-mail. I actually told her on...THREE? occasions I no longer wanted to talk to her via text or e-mail because it's hard to really show emotion, and they can ruin a relationship. It never panned out.

A couple of the other ones don't fit. She had no problem with intimacy...on a physical level. She was very touchy in a romantic sense, loved holding hands, loved to kiss, had a very high sex drive, and I had no complaints there. BUT...there's a second part to intimacy, emotional and psychological intimacy.

There's a really great line in that article.You might deny your need for closeness and feel that your partner wants too much of your time; your partner complains that you're unavailable, but he or she is denying his or her need for separateness.I barely fucking saw her some weeks, asked for slightly more, and I got a response where she got all weepy and barely talked to me for two days. It was not a healthy response.

I have another female friend who said she was afraid of getting too close to anyone...perhaps jaded from past relationships. Her mom LOVED me...she made jokes about us getting married some day...she cooked food just for me...I bought her mom (and dad) gifts on occasion, frequently brought wine to drink, etcetera.

There's so many things at play here. I don't doubt she really loved me...but she's got a really fucked up, abusive, co-dependent family. She's simply not healthy psychologically.

If I sit and think about it, there were other weird tinges of shit she said that didn't sit with me well. We frequently talked about moving in together some day, moving somewhere else (she was slated for getting a job overseas at one point, as mentioned in the old thread,) and we talked about going together. Then, after all the talk about living together...she made a comment once "we could be in a long distance relationship."

Which - - surprise surprise - - is what her last boyfriend of almost a year was, as mentioned above. I think she LIKES long distance relationships because, to her, they're stress free. She can do whatever the fuck she wants, she's not forced to do anything off her schedule, and you can just fucking text every night in lieu of getting close to someone.

Which at the same time is odd, because when we WERE together, she was all over me...she would kiss me in public places, we'd hold hands, we'd have sex nearly more than I could handle some days...like twice at night, once in the morning, then twice again the next night...then we'd go 3 weeks without fucking because I could barely see her sometimes.

What a fucking mess. Anyway...she's got issues. The sad part is, all I wish I could do is chain her and her entire family up and drag them to a psychiatrist and make them know they're fucked up and get them help. I say that benevolently. As fucked up as that breakup was, I want her to be healthy...but I don't think she knows how fucked up she is, and she doesn't even probably know what codependency is. She's gonna spend the rest of her life all out of whack and never being able to forge real relationships, and it makes me sad to think about.

For everything bad I said about her, she was really sweet and did do nice things for me, and she was a really good person to all those around her.
 

Julian The Apostate

Vyemm Raider
2,341
2,450
Thanks for the words. It's an interesting read.

I'll give you some more breakdown on this chick without getting into a ton of specifics. She was really special to me because she was European from a country I really love, I know some of the language...it was so unique finding her here because it's pretty much unheard of, as this is not a huge metropolitan area. She really was one in a million in that regard.

I've went over this with friends and girl friends up and down...they've sort of told me the same thing. It's usually men who fear commitment and getting close to someone, but she's a female and had all the tell-tale signs.

She's 40 years old...she has an ex-pat family who has moved all around the world her entire life. Her parents, who used to work for the government of said country, moved every few years (her dad was a diplomat.) She's lived in the U.S. most of her life. She's never been married, has no kids, but she's been engaged twice, and was once in a 7 year relationship, her longest. In the past 10 years, she's been with me and one other dude...the last dude only lasted 9 months, long distance, she said they were only together like a month in reality.

She's really quite nice looking...looks way younger than her age...and has only had two boyfriends in the past 10 years. That's sort of a red flag in itself.

Here's another huuuuuuuuuuge thing. She's up her parent's ASS. Like mad. She lost her last good job...she's been living with them again. They're quite reasonably wealthy and her dad's grandfather is a reasonably famous impressionist artist. Someone told me she's codependent...so I looked up the symptoms of codependency...holy FUCK if she didn't match every single last one.

There were some WTF moments I had with her, and I realized after reading some of this shit, it all jived.

Symptoms of Codependency | Psych Central

Low self esteem...she would think the WORST of anything I said to her sometimes. Like, even if it was good, she'd take it the wrong way. I can't think of a ton of examples, but it happened more than once, and here's one. After she first met my parents (who loved her,) I said to her one day "So, my mom said something about you last night." Her response instantly was "Oh, she thinks I'm too old for you, doesn't she?" I was like "Um, no, she'd never say that...she said you were really sweet and she enjoyed dinner with you."

People pleasing...out the ass as well. I saw her do where she worked...won't get into more details, but it was there.

Reactivity...goes along a lot with things I'd say and she'd give weird responses to.

Caretaking...with her parents? Jesus christ. She cooked, cleaned, took care of the cars, washed their cars, watered the hundred plants a day in the big ass house they had, cleaned all the dishes at night after the big ass dinners they always had, etcetera. I could go on and on.

Control...some details like time ALWAYS had to be her way. I frequently picked activities we did, but time? Fucking forget it. She hardly had any, despite working part time after losing her full time job. This was a big thing when I know I made her sad once...because I said I needed a bit more time a week than she was giving.

Get this shit...we live 20 minutes away. I work a full time job, I go to the gym, the park, I have shit to do. She lost her career...she's working part time as a WAITRESS. She was working 16 goddamn hours a week. Some weeks I saw her 0 to 3 hours a week...OCCASIONALLY she would spend time at my house, and occasionally we went on a weekend getaway, and RARELY I slept at her house...our "date nights" were strictly Wednesday and Saturday...NO DEVIATION. That was the days. She played tennis like 30 fucking hours a week...and some Saturdays I couldn't see her...WHY? Because her dad is involved in the golf and country club they live in...and, by her terminology, she would actually say this to me: "Dad is making me go to (insert event here) to take pictures." This is a fucking 40 year old woman, mind you. Who says her dad is MAKING her go somewhere. Oh...and she has a 4 year degree from a respected university. As stated, she's 40 years old...guess what the longest job she's ever had is? FOUR YEARS. She doesn't commit to shit.

And about her dad...he was nice to me...but holy hell is emotionally abusive to his wife. He would snap and yell at her WHILE I WAS THERE at their house eating dinner...and she did nothing to provoke it. They did this very early on in my knowing them, he had no shame in yelling at her. Mind you this was in another language most of the time, so I didn't catch most of it...sometimes I didn't even realize they were at each other so much, then my girlfriend would tell me later "I know you didn't understand everything, but my parents were arguing the entire night."

Back to that list of codependency...

Dysfunctional communication...holy mother of god this might be #1. She was impossible to talk to in person. She'd clam up...she actually told me once that she better communicates feelings and deep things in text rather than in person. This all ties into her breaking up with me via e-mail. I actually told her on...THREE? occasions I no longer wanted to talk to her via text or e-mail because it's hard to really show emotion, and they can ruin a relationship. It never panned out.

A couple of the other ones don't fit. She had no problem with intimacy...on a physical level. She was very touchy in a romantic sense, loved holding hands, loved to kiss, had a very high sex drive, and I had no complaints there. BUT...there's a second part to intimacy, emotional and psychological intimacy.

There's a really great line in that article.You might deny your need for closeness and feel that your partner wants too much of your time; your partner complains that you?re unavailable, but he or she is denying his or her need for separateness.I barely fucking saw her some weeks, asked for slightly more, and I got a response where she got all weepy and barely talked to me for two days. It was not a healthy response.

I have another female friend who said she was afraid of getting too close to anyone...perhaps jaded from past relationships. Her mom LOVED me...she made jokes about us getting married some day...she cooked food just for me...I bought her mom (and dad) gifts on occasion, frequently brought wine to drink, etcetera.

There's so many things at play here. I don't doubt she really loved me...but she's got a really fucked up, abusive, co-dependent family. She's simply not healthy psychologically.

If I sit and think about it, there were other weird tinges of shit she said that didn't sit with me well. We frequently talked about moving in together some day, moving somewhere else (she was slated for getting a job overseas at one point, as mentioned in the old thread,) and we talked about going together. Then, after all the talk about living together...she made a comment once "we could be in a long distance relationship."

Which - - surprise surprise - - is what her last boyfriend of almost a year was, as mentioned above. I think she LIKES long distance relationships because, to her, they're stress free. She can do whatever the fuck she wants, she's not forced to do anything off her schedule, and you can just fucking text every night in lieu of getting close to someone.

Which at the same time is odd, because when we WERE together, she was all over me...she would kiss me in public places, we'd hold hands, we'd have sex nearly more than I could handle some days...like twice at night, once in the morning, then twice again the next night...then we'd go 3 weeks without fucking because I could barely see her sometimes.

What a fucking mess. Anyway...she's got issues. The sad part is, all I wish I could do is chain her and her entire family up and drag them to a psychiatrist and make them know they're fucked up and get them help. I say that benevolently. As fucked up as that breakup was, I want her to be healthy...but I don't think she knows how fucked up she is, and she doesn't even probably know what codependency is. She's gonna spend the rest of her life all out of whack and never being able to forge real relationships, and it makes me sad to think about.

For everything bad I said about her, she was really sweet and did do nice things for me, and she was a really good person to all those around her.
There is a frightening amount of similarities between her and my soon to be ex-wife. You dodged a fucking bullet on that on bro. Be thankful and move on to someone more emotionally stable.


Edit: Wow, just read the Co-dependency link and holy fuck. Mind blown at how accurate that is for my ex.
 

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,662
16,106
The breakup was in December. I was talking about marriage with her in that thread early last year.

It's been over two months, and yeah, it still fucking sucks. I just can't let it bother me anymore. No fucking closure...not a chance to talk, ask questions, nothing. Completely ignored. She wouldn't even answer any questions I had. The sad thing is I'm also friends with some of her friends, and I hear shit about her. She's not dating, she doesn't do shit...she wasn't doing shit before I found her, either, she was single for _six_ fucking years, because she moves around constantly. Anyway, not gonna get into all those details.
Sounds like you may have figured it out, but the chick is broken, you were lucky to get out. Odds are the only reason she broke up is because she was afraid of falling for you or disappointing you or something along those lines. There. no reason to ponder it any longer. The only bad part about this is that if you are drawn to broken chicks, this is going to make you want to get back together with her even more.

All that being said, 40 yr olds trip my trigger. Can we get a pic, and maybe a phone number since she's available?
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,945
7,732
Sounds like you may have figured it out, but the chick is broken, you were lucky to get out. Odds are the only reason she broke up is because she was afraid of falling for you or disappointing you or something along those lines. There. no reason to ponder it any longer. The only bad part about this is that if you are drawn to broken chicks, this is going to make you want to get back together with her even more.

All that being said, 40 yr olds trip my trigger. Can we get a pic, and maybe a phone number since she's available?
I've went over the whole thing backwards and forwards with female friends who know 20 times more information than I've posted here, over the course of the entire relationship. One of these females in particular is Ms. Relationship Doctor who reads like every book on relationships and commitment and dysfunction that comes around.

Their consensus is she really loved me but has a history of being scared to commit to anyone or anything, which ties in with the codependency. They also mentioned at times the avoidant personality or whatever it is. Even they were both rather surprised by the e-mail breakup, though. There's some other disorder they think she has too. They think she was falling in love deeper and deeper and it scared her.

I am not drawn to broken women, I just happened upon this one. I have been in relationships with healthy women. I saw signs a long time ago with this one, I just didn't act on them. I knew she was bad at communication from early on, I was hurt by it after we started getting intimate and closer, and I even tried to bring it up, and she would just clam up and be sad for a few days and barely talk to me. I knew she was not quite right then.

The sad thing is with these chicks...I'm a good dude. I am good at communicating, I have loads of empathy...I would so gently reach out to her and she'd still flip out. No matter how sincere and nice I was, it just didn't work. So, I feel sorry for her, but as someone who is mentally competent, I know I require someone who can communicate.

I have pics of her, yes, but sorry, I don't do posting pics of myself or others on the internet. If you can imagine a 5'6, 140 pound, 40 year old European woman who played tennis 20+ hours a week (sorry I'm being vague about the country,) who my parents and friends all thought was my age, 32c boobs, always permanently tan from being outside...she was rather nice looking. I'm not saying she's a supermodel or anything, but she really looked nice, always very neatly dressed, and had beautiful, long hair, great, white teeth, and wonderful eyes. She's by far the oldest woman I've ever dated, and the age was never a thing to me (I'm only 34, by the way.) It's probably for the best for that reason, though, who knows if I want kids some day, and it wasn't going to happen with her.

To be honest, had she not been European, I probably would not have asked her out. The fact I'm obsessed with this country and found a single woman here in this podunk place from said country was to be honest really fascinating to me. I got to meet a lot of her family and be exposed to the culture more closely than I ever had been, and so on.
 

Venetir_sl

shitlord
9
0
I've went over the whole thing backwards and forwards with female friends who know 20 times more information than I've posted here, over the course of the entire relationship. One of these females in particular is Ms. Relationship Doctor who reads like every book on relationships and commitment and dysfunction that comes around.

Their consensus is she really loved me but has a history of being scared to commit to anyone or anything, which ties in with the codependency. They also mentioned at times the avoidant personality or whatever it is. Even they were both rather surprised by the e-mail breakup, though. There's some other disorder they think she has too. They think she was falling in love deeper and deeper and it scared her.

I am not drawn to broken women, I just happened upon this one. I have been in relationships with healthy women. I saw signs a long time ago with this one, I just didn't act on them. I knew she was bad at communication from early on, I was hurt by it after we started getting intimate and closer, and I even tried to bring it up, and she would just clam up and be sad for a few days and barely talk to me. I knew she was not quite right then.

The sad thing is with these chicks...I'm a good dude. I am good at communicating, I have loads of empathy...I would so gently reach out to her and she'd still flip out. No matter how sincere and nice I was, it just didn't work. So, I feel sorry for her, but as someone who is mentally competent, I know I require someone who can communicate.

I have pics of her, yes, but sorry, I don't do posting pics of myself or others on the internet. If you can imagine a 5'6, 140 pound, 40 year old European woman who played tennis 20+ hours a week (sorry I'm being vague about the country,) who my parents and friends all thought was my age, 32c boobs, always permanently tan from being outside...she was rather nice looking. I'm not saying she's a supermodel or anything, but she really looked nice, always very neatly dressed, and had beautiful, long hair, great, white teeth, and wonderful eyes. She's by far the oldest woman I've ever dated, and the age was never a thing to me (I'm only 34, by the way.) It's probably for the best for that reason, though, who knows if I want kids some day, and it wasn't going to happen with her.

To be honest, had she not been European, I probably would not have asked her out. The fact I'm obsessed with this country and found a single woman here in this podunk place from said country was to be honest really fascinating to me. I got to meet a lot of her family and be exposed to the culture more closely than I ever had been, and so on.
I don't post too much, but this struck a chord with me just because it's so similar to what I've been through and mine ended right on New Years day, close to December there with basically the same conclusion, just via a three page text.

I agree with what everyone else has been saying; as much as it hurts it's best to know now what you do and let go, work on the mourning process and come to an understanding that it's not you, it just didn't work. It could have been a multitude of reasons; she could have been scared like Iannis said, in that she became attached and she felt she shouldn't or inadequacy issues. Maybe she did love you too much and once the realization of it all hit, she just couldn't take coping with that and went running. Again, not that you pushed her to it or did anything to cause it, but some people fear that life of commitment because of past issues.

For me what helped was just as you are doing; talk to your friends, vent here and let it out. Hell cry it out if you need too more, because the person you once believed to be there is no longer there. As much as I still love and care for my ex, the hardest thing to accept was that it was over, and even if we got back together I would always have that looming fear she would run again even if she promised it would be different this time. But I know, once you feel like this person is the "one" for you and you care so much, it's hard to understand or wrap your head around how they could so easily just toss it all aside after all the promises, moments shared and the start of a life together.

But there is no logic in love or relationships from what I've seen. It either just works or it ends up falling apart. For what it's worth, you seem to have yourself together on a level of communication and empathy that someone else is out there dying for, and it's just a matter of time before you find that person who can appreciate all of those qualities and not be terrified of them because of their own issues.

No matter what venting you do or advice you get though, the process is yours and take as much time as you need to heal from it. Mine still burns and I still wake up sometimes really upset, but I know that it will get better and once I was able to talk it out more, it felt like a huge weight off my shoulders.

Good luck in how you handle it, all the best because I know it's hell for quite some time.
 

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,662
16,106
I have pics of her, yes, but sorry, I don't do posting pics of myself or others on the internet. If you can imagine a 5'6, 140 pound, 40 year old European woman who played tennis 20+ hours a week (sorry I'm being vague about the country,) who my parents and friends all thought was my age, 32c boobs, always permanently tan from being outside...she was rather nice looking. I'm not saying she's a supermodel or anything, but she really looked nice, always very neatly dressed, and had beautiful, long hair, great, white teeth, and wonderful eyes.
I understand. Just PM it to me.

Thanks
 

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,662
16,106
I have pics of her, yes, but sorry, I don't do posting pics of myself or others on the internet. If you can imagine a 5'6, 140 pound, 40 year old European woman who played tennis 20+ hours a week (sorry I'm being vague about the country,) who my parents and friends all thought was my age, 32c boobs, always permanently tan from being outside...she was rather nice looking. I'm not saying she's a supermodel or anything, but she really looked nice, always very neatly dressed, and had beautiful, long hair, great, white teeth, and wonderful eyes.
I understand. Just PM it to me.

Thanks
 

Dabamf_sl

shitlord
1,472
0
This is actually something that Dabamf would be very good at. There are personality attributes based on childhood attachment to parents. Maybe he'll swoop in here and correct me (which would be fine, because this is stuff that I misremember poorly), but it sounds like she might have some of the traits of a avoidant attachment. You'll never get closure out of this type of person. It's not even that they're trying to be cruel, or disdainful -- it's just not how theythink.

I mean it sounds like astrology, but it's not really. Individuals themselves cannot be quantified -- but groups of them can be studied and bonding patterns do emerge. And then you have to make up silly sounding words to express those patterns with.

It may not be the case, it probably isn't.I mention it because I had a girl like this and it nagged at me for over a year, and I'm pretty sure it was the case for me (as sure as you can be without eliciting the confession of her psychiatrist under torture). But it seems to me that lacking closure, the next best thing is intellectual comprehension. She might have really liked you, and it spooked her down to her very fucking soul. If that happened there's not a fucking thing you can do about it. Or I might be completely full of shit and she's just a cold bitch who just decided she didn't like you that much to begin with -- and again, there's nothing you can do about it. It's really just a different way to say, "Bitch be crazy"... but the process of examining the specifics is just somehow more emotionally satisfying. I suppose that it's because it allows you to say, in hindsight and perhaps wrongly and only for your own pride, "Well... that was doomed to begin with."

But that's still better than nothing.
I don't know much about attachment really. Early attachment style with parents (secure, anxious, avoidant; see Mary Ainsworth wiki) does often predict adult attachment style, but there are plenty of other factors that also contribute to how people act in relationships. Whatever the case, the girl clearly has unhealthy relationship behaviors and you'll objectively be better off without her in the long run.

As for codependency, I don't know much about that either other than it's not a real thing in psychology. I mean, nothing really is (diagnoses are just descriptions of "these things tend to go together"), but I think there's another diagnosis that captures that pattern in a more meaningful and less "Barnum effect"y way. Sounds maybe like avoidant personality disorder..? I'm a first year, lay off.

Jackie, the girl showed massive warning signs. It sucks, and I'm sympathetic, but for the peace of mind of future-you, you absolutely could have seen it coming, and you will in the future. Those behaviors are not healthy relationship behaviors.

Also, be weary of the advice of your coworkers. "She loved you so much she couldn't take it" sounds a lot like psychobabble bullshit. A good rule of thumb for psychology theories is that if they sound too cool or fancy or rely on opposites (eg he/she did xyz because he/she feels abc), they are probably bullshit. Check her library: if she has read any John Gray books (men are from mars) she's reading pseudopsychology.

Anyway, if the codependence thing makes sense of her behavior, then it's useful. Look out in the future and follow the path of Onoes
 

Izo

Tranny Chaser
19,635
23,972
Why the fuck aren't the naked pics of Onoes chicks in here? WHAT THE FUCK?
I am on a quest to find them but I think they are gone forever unless he reposts them.
For posterity.

rrr_img_61234.jpg

rrr_img_61235.jpg

rrr_img_61236.jpg
Nets. We need them. Mods are worthless.
 

skribble

Golden Knight of the Realm
488
136
Long story, but need some advice. Basically, im a mature (30s) student returning to University to leave a job I hated and do a job I really want to do. However, its a predominently female field and my class is like 90-100% girls. Most of my friends at the minute are girls, and they are very young (18-22) and honestly the lectures feel like high school all over again (constant bitching/drama/etc). It is not my scene at all.

Anyway, I did it hit it off with one of the girls in my small circle of friends. Instant chemistry, but she had a boyfriend. After various nights out we ended up getting together (sleeping together). We'd been drinking all day, and she maintained she blacked out (in the sense she doesnt remember, she was perfectly coherent the entire time) and we never talked about it after, and just stayed friends. After that there were a few near misses, but we ended up making out on a nightclub again after she admits to some mutual friend she did remember kissing me (though doesnt mention sex). So we go back to hers and her room, and this time I do the gentlemanly thing for some reason and say I can stay over but no sex, since she has a boyfriend. She initiated a little, but gave up and I stayed over.

Again, this was not mentioned the next day, and we continued as friends. After xmas, she went on holiday with her boyfriend, and acted differently around me. We had another night out but she was really distant, all over some gay/bi guy etc. and wouldn't be alone with me. I kind of bumped into friends so peaced out from her and when i was leaving she asked me to give her a call when I was home, I told her to ring me instead and she did. So I went up to hers and there were all these people hanging out, and i basically said that i came to see her not these douchebags, and we came up with a plan for her to go to bed and I came in and met her.

However, when I tried to initiate , nothing. Basically rolled over and just let me spoon her. Wouldn't make eye contact. I felt like a fucking cuddle buddy or something, and just basically stated my intentions and that I wasnt there to be her cuddle friend when her and her bf had a fight or whatever or she needed validation. She says she really likes me, shes just really "confused", and cried a bit. Felt guilty about cheating. Im not sure I believed her. The conversation of sex came up and I informed her we'd already had it, and she seemed totally taken aback. I was like "why the hell did you think you woke up naked?", and she seemed kind of shocked. Again, I dunno what to believe. I stayed late until the morning that night, but nothing happened.

Last time we all went out, she was again being distant, being all over her bi-sexual friend etc. and I was getting irritated so just grabbed her at one point, tried to kiss her, and asked her wtf was up. I was pretty drunk but the basic gist of it was that she felt really guilty, shes not a "cheater" and if we went home (i wanted to leave) we'd just end up in her bed, and sometimes her bf is really nice to her(?). Gives me a peck then proceeds to slut about the nightclub a bit.

She is also a bit of a tease, and I'd be very wary of this if it wasn't for the fact we'd banged already.

Anyway. Dunno what the fuck to do, and its messing with my brain to the point its fucking up my study. I didn't plan on falling for this girl and what seemed like some good fun is getting to be a serious distraction. She lives in the same dorms, so I basically have to walk with her every day, and is in my close group of friends and my lectures. I know that for me, distant and cutting ties is the best idea but its just impossible with this chick, and its really getting on my tits. So I don't know what to do or what my next move should be. Any advice ?
 

Kirun

Buzzfeed Editor
19,505
15,882
Anyway. Dunno what the fuck to do, and its messing with my brain to the point its fucking up my study. I didn't plan on falling for this girl and what seemed like some good fun is getting to be a serious distraction. She lives in the same dorms, so I basically have to walk with her every day, and is in my close group of friends and my lectures. I know that for me, distant and cutting ties is the best idea but its just impossible with this chick, and its really getting on my tits. So I don't know what to do or what my next move should be. Any advice ?
Two things:

1. You landed yourself firmly in the "friend zone" by not following up on her advances, especially the part where you did the "gentlemanly" thing.

2. Why in the hell would you want to fuck with a chick who is cheating on her boyfriend with you? You honestly think she won't do the same to you? You'd be an absolute moron to want anything serious with this girl.
 

skribble

Golden Knight of the Realm
488
136
Two things:

1. You landed yourself firmly in the "friend zone" by not following up on her advances, especially the part where you did the "gentlemanly" thing.

2. Why in the hell would you want to fuck with a chick who is cheating on her boyfriend with you? You honestly think she won't do the same to you? You'd be an absolute moron to want anything serious with this girl.
Yeah, I realize she's toxic. But emotions aren't rational and if I spend time with her I can't help liking her, thats the problem.
Also, about the friendzone .. Im not even sure she remembers that, and we did make out that night at least. Though maybe you are right, I have no fucking idea. Thats probably why I was so insistent im not just going to be a "cuddle buddy", and tried to kiss her that night and stated my intentions, and tried to kiss her since.
 

skribble

Golden Knight of the Realm
488
136
Burn that bridge down asap and move the fuck on unless you're happy being used and treated like shit. Fuck getting emotional over some crazy bitch.
Which would be my normal plan. I have no problem cutting ties im usually pretty good at it. But she lives in my building, we walk to class together, we are in the small same group for everything in class and outside. Im not sure how to go about it.