The Girls Who Broke Your Heart Thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Dabamf_sl

shitlord
1,472
0
I think you were fine until you said "don't worry about it." It either comes off as excusing her behavior or passive-aggressive, neither of which you want.

And why the hell can I analyze that just fine, but when I'm in the same situation myself, I screw it up?
Yea I think that's a fair assessment. Ideally I probably should have dropped it before those last 2 texts and ignored the excuse

If she makes an effort to recontact I'll probably see her again because she is fucking cute (and Asian - cute doesn't influence me to be irrational anymore unless she's also asian) and witty as hell. But in absence of that, blowing me off was strike 1 and 2, and seemingly not really understanding why it was rude is strike 3.
 

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,804
99,987
It's not like she showed up 20 minutes late. Shecancelled20 minutes after being expected. That wastes a lot more than 20 minutes of Dabamf's time. She easily could have cancelled on him ahead of time if she wanted to make plans with her "friend leaving town".

Fuck her.
This is a tinder girl were talking about.
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
And? There is no point in dating someone who shows you from the get go they don't value your time. It's an inevitability that it will happen again. The fact that she's a tindr girl means she's just that much easier to replace.
 

Antarius

Lord Nagafen Raider
1,828
15
Did she get the aborsh Antarius?
Yes she aborted, and I'm 90% certain I was the father, we had marathon sex the weekend she got pregnant, I probably came inside her at least 6 times. She was with me all weekend, and the estimated age of the baby was right in the middle of my 3 day weekend with her.

BUT, I also found out she had started flirting and texting a "friend" of hers (her words, I'd call him an ex), right about the time she got pregnant. It made a lot more sense to me why I stopped feeling like she gave a shit... Because she didn't. She had stopped sending me friendly and flirty texts throughout the day and was doing it with him. So it made sense why I felt like the relationship imploded over the 2 months she was pregnant, I'm sure some of it was hormonal, but a lot of it was she was looking to jump to that next branch. Hell, in my worst nightmare she was probably thinking about him when we did have sex.

I got the babysitting and the throwing up and the tired all the time girlfriend who didn't want to have sex and when he initiated felt like he had to force himself on her. He got the happy, flirtatious, positive girl. The last month before I broke up with her (looked at her Verizon account), she sent me 100 texts, she sent him 500.

What really cemented things for me was WHAT she was sending him... when she was 6 weeks pregnant, she sent him "I'm bored, I wish you were here to come cuddle with me" (he declined). During her first visit to the abortion clinic, when we found out the baby was almost 10 weeks along already she told him "He's such a retard, I can't believe he'd even have second thoughts about keeping it". After her abortion, when I was crying in the car, she texted him "He's such a jerk, I can't believe I'm having to comfort HIM, it's supposed to be the opposite"

Those were tough to read. She's been begging me to come back, that she still loves me, that she never wants anyone else but me, and that she would rather live alone than be with anyone other than me... But I know she's just bullshitting me, She was trying to set up dates within a week of me breaking up with her. My guess is she got railed by another guy before her abortion and now he just stopped responding to her, so she's having a "grass isn't always greener" feeling.
 

Famm

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
11,041
794
High five! Or, like, if you have feelings about that or something....then feels bro and stuff.
 

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
15,956
9,365
I pulled the same shit with my now wife. She canceled on my and i told her my time was valuable and if it was legitimate then understood but don't waste my or both our times otherwise.

She still talks about it sometimes and said she respected the shit out of me from that moment on.

Other than the "don't worry about it" i think you were pretty gold with the whole thing.
 

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,804
99,987
And? There is no point in dating someone who shows you from the get go they don't value your time. It's an inevitability that it will happen again. The fact that she's a tindr girl means she's just that much easier to replace.
It should be obvious with the nature of tinder that there is going to be a lot of flakes. Thats like going into a bar/club and being pissed some girls are just hoping to score free drinks off you.
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,944
7,718
Not a "girl who broke your heart" issue, but I guess this fits into the thread for lack of a better place. We didn't get close enough for any heartbreak.

I went out with this woman for a few weeks recently. Early 30's, very nice style and clothes, petite, great skin, very pretty face ( but a bit skinnier than I like women to be honest.) She has a four year degree and a good job. Very outwardly kind and empathetic, we went to a few dinners, some cultural this and that, a show, walked around the city sometimes showing each other things, and so on. A good time was had by all, lots of communication in between dates, positive vibes. Ended up in bed a couple of times in the last week, everything was fine. More than fine, even, she seemed elated and gave off obvious hints I was doing everything right. So, I was digging this whole thing pretty well.

I sent her a text, nothing out of the ordinary. She replies back two hours later very curtly and with no explanation "I'm not really feeling things with you, and you text too much." So, I was like ooookay. Bear in mind she initiated communication more than I did, so I know that wasn't true. I consider myself really good at keeping communication even-keeled with the other person and not being overbearing. So I thought to myself that's a weird thing to say when things were seemingly going so well. I was almost more bemused by it than saddened. I asked her why she felt that way and if I said or did something wrong, and she replied back with the same thing.

Here's where shit gets weird. Normally, given the information, I'd Google-fu the shit out of someone as soon as possible, but for whatever reason, I hadn't got to it yet with her. So I Google her full name. It finds an old Myspace account. Old Myspace account name is an internet nickname. I Google her nickname...what do I find? Forums where she discusses having borderline personality disorder spanning back several years. Fuck's sake! Everything was too good to be true. I confirmed it was her, talking about the city she lives in, correct details, and it was a really unique moniker.

In a roundabout way, I confronted her with it without saying I found out she had it, in an e-mail. She responded back "I have no such thing! You shouldn't accuse me of that, don't write me again, blah blah blah." Then she said "never contact me again." An hour later: "I'm sorry, but you shouldn't have told me I have BPD, you should have asked," along with some other stuff. Said once again: "This will be my last message to you." I responded back, paraphrasing from a longer e-mail, which I wrote very kindly: "I understand, sorry for accusing you of having BPD, if you'd ever like to talk about it, feel free to e-mail me."

So a few days pass with no contact. Surprise! I see an e-mail from her again, after being told twice she wouldn't contact me again.

"I received a notification someone has been trying to access my gmail account. I don't know if it was you, but please stop if you are, because it's creepy and inappropriate. Sorry if you aren't the one doing it, I apologize, and please disregard this message if so."

I very calmly told her "I don't even know your gmail address, ergo I have no way to attempt such a thing, nor would I if I could." Which is true, I don't even know her gmail address.

Reading about BPD this weekend (I had only heard of it before) I found out it is a hallmark of BPD people to just flip on you for no reason, and to make accusations out of the clear blue.

Oy. What an interesting ride that was. I somehow don't think she'll stay away, either. Looking back while knowing now she has BPD I can sort of pick up on things I missed the first time around. For instance, I don't think she's ever had a long term relationship before, for obvious reasons. Made some hints about trust issues and other things too, but I had at first dismissed them as typical stuff women say.
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
You've got to embellish more than that for sympathy around here. Your story does you no favors even if everything you say is true.

"This girl let me down easy and mentioned I was texting her too much even though I totally wasn't! So I e-stalked her and confronted her out of the blue with the fact she was bi-polar and she denied it! Fucking crazy bitches right?"
 

TheBeagle

JunkiesNetwork Donor
8,939
30,987
Story about a date with a bipolar bear
TL;DR

rrr_img_72200.jpg
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,944
7,718
You've got to embellish more than that for sympathy around here. Your story does you no favors even if everything you say is true.

"This girl let me down easy and mentioned I was texting her too much even though I totally wasn't! So I e-stalked her and confronted her out of the blue with the fact she was bi-polar and she denied it! Fucking crazy bitches right?"
I'm not looking for sympathy, I wasn't close to her, so no hard feelings on my end with her. She doesn't have bi-polar, she has BPD (borderline personality disorder.) It was just a story, that's all.
 

Blazin

Creative Title
<Nazi Janitors>
7,132
36,635
In a roundabout way, I confronted her with it without saying I found out she had it, in an e-mail.
This was over the line imo . I dont think there is wrong with a little google fu on a person you are forming a relationship with but sounds like you may have taken it too far to come off as anything but a little over zealous/creeper. You doing the checking after she started trying to distance from you make it look worse to her. I'm sure it sucks when things go south with someone that you were clicking with but you need to just let this one go. (and do your google'ing at first date not for the purpose of confronting but knowing when to run)
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,944
7,718
This was over the line imo . I dont think there is wrong with a little google fu on a person you are forming a relationship with but sounds like you may have taken it too far to come off as anything but a little over zealous/creeper. You doing the checking after she started trying to distance from you make it look worse to her. I'm sure it sucks when things go south with someone that you were clicking with but you need to just let this one go.
Oh, I have no interest in dating someone with mental illness, so I assure you, this won't go any further. I had been ignoring her, then she sends me an e-mail accusing me of trying to access her Gmail account, which I don't even know of (we e-mailed on her ISP e-mail.)

Her behavior is very typical of someone with BPD, from what I've found.

The Borderline Dance & The Non Borderline Quagmire - Borderline Personality Disorder Inside Out

Borderline Personality Disorder: Heroic Martyr or Emotional Vampire?

Scary shit. Just search "accus" in the second article (to find both accuse and accusations.)

People with BPD have been known to falsely accuse friends / family / significant others of sexually abusing them / being violent with them / stealing, lying, and so on. Yeah, not my cup of tea. It's another thing with them that they come on very strong in relationships and act as if everything is perfect, then turn off at the drop of a hat.
 

TheBeagle

JunkiesNetwork Donor
8,939
30,987
Honestly bro, after you confronting her with your googlefu results, I think it's natural for her to assume you might be the one accessing her gmail account. Looking at it from her perspective it seems like a pretty big coincidence that in the same time frame, a guy she went out on a date with confronts her with her with some details about her personal life he learned by 'hacking my internetz' and then a short time later, her gmail acct gets hacked.

Obviously we all know how to googlefu, but your average hot chick with minimal interwebz experience probably thinks you are some kind of elite hacker to be able pull up all that info so easily.
 

Jackie Treehorn

<Gold Donor>
2,944
7,718
Honestly bro, after you confronting her with your googlefu results, I think it's natural for her to assume you might be the one accessing her gmail account. Looking at it from her perspective it seems like a pretty big coincidence that in the same time frame, a guy she went out on a date with confronts her with her with some details about her personal life he learned by 'hacking my internetz' and then a short time later, her gmail acct gets hacked.

Obviously we all know how to googlefu, but your average hot chick with minimal interwebz experience probably thinks you are some kind of elite hacker to be able pull up all that info so easily.
Yeah, I gotcha. That might be the logic she's using. The thing is too, though, she didn't say it was broken into...she said Google sent a warning for attempted account access.

I'm familiar with that alert, because some Chinese tried accessing my gmail a while back, and the Google alert very clearly tells you there was attempted access, but also states no actual login was made.

Screenshot here on Google's site of what those alerts look like:

Unusual activity alerts - Accounts Help

So, technically speaking, she knows I didn't access her gmail account. But yeah, the paranoia might still be there. Obviously someone doesn't just "figure out" you're BPD, so it was probably a shock to her.
 

TheBeagle

JunkiesNetwork Donor
8,939
30,987
Ya no biggie, but lesson learned. I dated a girl once that told me she was bipolar and I had to learn the hard way not to crack dumb jokes about it. Also learned not to date bipolar girls in general, but that's a different story.
 

iannis

Musty Nester
31,351
17,657
IT's just as well that you don't want to date her. You wouldn't be able to sustain anything meaningful anyway.

Borderlines won't let you.

Edit: I've found a lot of women will claim to be bipolar just because they've either been told that (and it might be true even) or... really just as an excuse for hormonal shifts that they don't want to control. And maybe they can't control, I don't know. A lot of white women were sent to a lot of psychologists as girls. More than you'd think, even. I hate to say it but it was trendy to do it.

I had a woman tell me one time that a doctor told her that her nervous system was "wired backwards" so that her reaction to stress was to zone out.

I didn't pick the fight but... lol... no he didn't tell you that. Maybe that's what you heard.