Yea, except Federal Student Aid. Not saying it isn't broken, but anyone can get loans to go to college and they will succeed if they are properly driven to. Doesn't mean those shitty failing industrial cities where they pay half as much for schools in some depressed areas are correct, but they can be overcome.I think, and the data support it, that the US has slid backwards as far as opportunity is concerned, and by a significant margin, versus what the past two generations had access to. It used to be that you could just show up to one of the many plentiful jobs and you'd get a chance to prove yourself. Now you've got to pay 40k-160k for an education first before you even get a CHANCE to get a job before you get ANOTHER CHANCE to prove yourself. And even once you DO prove yourself, the share of the pie you're going to get is the smallest it's been in 40 years. And all the military vets in this thread boggle my fucking mind, because you guys are getting shit on in this job market more than anyone else, statistically speaking.
On my other point, all I'm saying is that if you're a college admissions officer or a graduate admissions officer evaluating the POTENTIAL of a given candidate, you're not doing your due diligence if you only look at the finish line and totally disregard where the candidate started at.
And I personally HATE the term privilege, but its a lot better than white guilt. Because it's NOT about feeling guilty for whatyouhave, 'checking your privilege' is about giving proper respect to those others that got to the same place you're at if they had a harder road to travel to get there.
I'm going to tell a story.On my other point, all I'm saying is that if you're a college admissions officer or a graduate admissions officer evaluating the POTENTIAL of a given candidate, you're not doing your due diligence if you only look at the finish line and totally disregard where the candidate started at.
It should just be white bias, because everyone is biased. Some biases work out positively and others negatively.How about advantage? White advantage doesn't make me rage like white privilege does.
Let's not even get into the personal anecdotes here, because if we're going the 'my momma so poor' stories I'm sure I've got most of you beat. I remember eating the macaroni necklace we made at school because there was nothing else to fucking eat. And I grew up in public housing so moldy and decrepit that I had scars on my lungs like someone who'd been smoking for 30 years, didn't grow out of the asthma and chronic bronchitis they caused until I was in my mid 20s.I'm going to tell a story.
When I went back into college after my time in the United States Army after learning how to rig explosives and lay mines and barbed wire (which I'm legit good at, btw. I could put together a 10 row that would stop a tank) I majored in Criminal Justice and then later Political Science as well. One of my POLS teachers goes to Mexico every other year and does charity work for some local tribe. It sounded interesting but I didn't have the money for it so the professor told me I should apply for aid. Some people get their whole trip paid for.
So I go and apply. I fill out all the paperwork at the international studies office of the school that handles all that stuff and decides who gets what money. When it comes back I go and talk to the woman in charge. She's of some dark skinned ethnicity. She tells me that I've qualified for what amounted to 15% of the total cost of the trip. When I tell her that I was hoping for more help she recommends that for my birthday and for Christmas I ask for money rather than gifts. She's 100% serious. I drove here in an ancient used car. I'm sitting here wearing a second hand shirt, pants, coat, and shoes, and her big idea is for me to ask for money rather than gifts. I don't know what the two women who also applied got but I know they went on that trip and I didn't. Guess how many white males (the majority) went, do you think? Fuck, guess how many males went in general?
My parents were so fucking poor we moved back in with grandma for 6 years of the initial part of their marriage (goddamn miracle they didn't break up) and I could only pay for school then because Uncle Sam taught me how to kill and I've got to deal with people correcting the gross injustices of the great white male patriarchy every chance they get. Because I'm privileged.
Part of the same "us vs. them" mentality that the other side is guilty of. That in order for one group to succeed, another has to suffer. And that just wouldn't be true if not for the fact that one tiny group is hogging all the money and political power.
I wish I could quit you.I remember eating the macaroni necklace we made at school because there was nothing else to fucking eat.
I wonder what this means. On paper this may make sense. If we draw it by ethnic and racial line there is no doubt that whites are hired more and earn more. That same number also suggests that yellow people are doing better than white people yet discrimination factor still applies. So if we go by Mist's analogy of a race, yellow people should have ended later and life was supposed to be much worse but each passing generation suggests otherwise. Yellow parents and children are now ahead of white people in the race and carved a respectable holding against and with white racial group.I could get down with white advantage.
Not if they're 24"+ on 1980's sedans.Are you saying chrome rims are a bad investment?
First thing you learn from job training for job seeker is "it's who you know" not just "what I know." This takes special kind of skills to develop.It should just be white bias, because everyone is biased. Some biases work out positively and others negatively.
The term privilege just came about because rich people like to call their kids 'privileged' rather than 'spoiled, morally vacant sacks of shit.' And then the term just generalized to just about all white college kids, which I feel is grossly unfair, but still carries a bit of weight because a white middle class kid has a better shot at getting into a fraternity that's going to further their career than a black middle class kid is.
The real problem with 'privilege' is that this country is slipping backwards from being a meritocracy, where hard work gets you ahead. Instead, it's mostly about the political connections you make at college. While this was always true to a certain degree, it's truer now more than it has been in a long time. And with the massively rising costs to college, it's becoming a major problem.
This thread overall is like Mos Eisley for stupid. I can't bear to read it all straight through.I wonder what this means. On paper this may make sense. If we draw it by ethnic and racial line there is no doubt that whites are hired more and earn more. That same number also suggests that yellow people are doing better than white people yet discrimination factor still applies. So if we go by Mist's analogy of a race, yellow people should have ended later and life was supposed to be much worse but each passing generation suggests otherwise. Yellow parents and children are now ahead of white people in the race and carved a respectable holding against and with white racial group.
The other problem is certain racial groups often teach exclusivity, primarily blacks and certain Asian cultures. The problem isn't that people can't have role models outside of their race, but rather that it is shoved down every little black kid's throat to be proud of black famous people simply because they are black, and at the exclusion of others. Public schools and society prioritize minority heroes. Black kids have this reinforced at home through their culture 'we gotta look after ourselves!'. It's unfortunate that because Andrew Jackson was white, no one can find worth in his character and accomplishments. So they all turn to drugged up sports stars, thugs, other famous people they identify with. Accomplished black people, like Obama or Dr. Neil DeGrasse Tyson are tossed aside as privileged or outsiders deep down when they exhibit the same traits black people associate with 'whites' - self-worth, work ethic, success. As soon as you aren't a victim, you're just 'one of them'. Again, victim-hood and racial identity over self-worth and empathy.This thread overall is like Mos Eisley for stupid. I can't bear to read it all straight through.
With regards to your post, Trollface, you have hit on something that I think is key in this "discussion": It has very little to do with race and very much to do with culture and family structure. It's not privilege, which is just shorthand for shutting down opposing viewpoints and continuing the politics of grievance. Kids growing up in stable, two parent households with an emphasis on education almost always do better. This is expressed racially by the cultural focus on this aspect of life. Americans of Asian descent as well as those of Jewish descent hold strongly to this, and as you progress down through "White", Hispanic, and Black social mores you can see success fall off.
Three things more than any other hold back Black successes: The dependence culture, including government programs which incentivize single parent families and public assistance; the adoption of Southern "Celtic Fringe" behaviors as "black culture" and acceptance of those behaviors; and self-segregation and failure to integrate into the mainstream, along with a culture of grievance, including in-group/out-group cohesion mechanisms (the successful as "uncle toms", those who achieve educationally being called "oreos", gangsters, rappers and athletes as idealized role models);
One only has to look at the success of African and Caribbean immigrants who identify as "black" vs. native-born Americans of African descent to see the part that culture plays in these outcomes, and the state of racial bias in the U.S.
Mists "America as evil" is literally the most egregiously and deliberately ignorant thing I have read in a long time.
If she were white she'd have a sport coat and a goatee.
if only she had privilege.