Szlia
Member
La La Land - That movie left me lukewarm. The romantic comedy element of it is underdeveloped. The music is... well... let's just say Hurwitz is not Gershwin nor Bernstein (in all fairness the two songs nominated for an academy award are the one that is good - City of Stars - and the one that goes along the most moving moment of the film - The Fools Who Dream). The choreography is not particularly exciting... Chazel's directing of the musical acts is on point, alternating dazzling tracking shots and sharp editing, and the performances of Stone and Gosling are commendable and the fact they are not amazing singers makes it more human and touching in a way. I really enjoyed their dancing, but, well... not Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. I don't know... as a retro musical, it is not as good as its models and as a modern musical it does not break the mold enough (it cracks it a little in the end) to convince... 6 or 7 out of 10? Probably less if you are not in love with Emma Stone (or, I guess, Ryan Gosling).
Manchester By The Sea - What is a drama? A film where dramatic things happen? By this definition Manchester By The Sea is not really a drama, but in a way it's worse: it's about trying to or failing to deal with the dramatic things that happened. Great performances, great dialogues laced with acerbic wit that provide some welcomed respite from the somber situation, I was also very impressed by the cinematography. The transition to digital cameras has been a rocky one at times (see some shots in Collateral or Public Enemy or the abomination that is The Hobbit), but now cinematographers are not only adept at providing a very cinematic look to movies shot with digital cameras, but they are also able to use them for things that would be impossible using film. The other day I saw Ta'ang, a documentary by chinese director Wang Bing, and there is a scene lit by a single flickering candle that at times goes to a barely red wick and there is not an ounce of video noise in the shot, it's insane. In Manchester By The Sea, it's the stunning sharpness of the general shots that amazes. 8 out of 10.
EDIT: Ryan Gosling not Ryan Reynolds... doh!
Manchester By The Sea - What is a drama? A film where dramatic things happen? By this definition Manchester By The Sea is not really a drama, but in a way it's worse: it's about trying to or failing to deal with the dramatic things that happened. Great performances, great dialogues laced with acerbic wit that provide some welcomed respite from the somber situation, I was also very impressed by the cinematography. The transition to digital cameras has been a rocky one at times (see some shots in Collateral or Public Enemy or the abomination that is The Hobbit), but now cinematographers are not only adept at providing a very cinematic look to movies shot with digital cameras, but they are also able to use them for things that would be impossible using film. The other day I saw Ta'ang, a documentary by chinese director Wang Bing, and there is a scene lit by a single flickering candle that at times goes to a barely red wick and there is not an ounce of video noise in the shot, it's insane. In Manchester By The Sea, it's the stunning sharpness of the general shots that amazes. 8 out of 10.
EDIT: Ryan Gosling not Ryan Reynolds... doh!
Last edited:
- 1