From my perspective, even if I was a rabid fan of the franchise a decade and a half ago, it's been soured enough that a new game can only be looked at askance at this point. I'm probably reading this wrong, but it seems to me people are in love with the idea of 1999-2004 EQ and completely forgot we've had nearly a decade of EQ2.
To me it's analogous to Star Wars. We love the original trilogy and we're very excited about the new stuff that's coming out in 2 years, but we've conveniently forgotten Eps 1-3. But now EQ is a sandbox so it's different and makes it interesting; the same with Star Wars because it's Disney and it gives us hope.