Sounds exactly like what I read about Blizzard on other sites. Point being developers get trashed all the time. It's not easy to make these games. They are complex and cannot possibly please everyone.
The difference is this board ACTUALLY went through things like cloth caps, alchemy and tons of other things where the developer simply lied--until they shut down their own boards to prevent the need for any explanations (Donals BP, lulz). We're not talking about failing to deliver on promises--we're talking about
active deceit, that was only allowed because they knew they were the only game in town.
Anyone comparing SoE's early years, to even Kotick's Blizzard, is either an delusional, or never experienced what the industry was like before competition enforced a kind of minimum standard. I mean, it's like comparing Mad Max with Baltimore, both are bad, but early SoE is the thunderdome of MMO bullshit.
But anyway, back to the point. Smed and company have been caught bold faced lying about products before--not missing targets or over-promising, but actual lies about supposedly finished products. Why do they get the benefit of the doubt now?
Did you or anyone in anyway see all of EQN coming? No. Me neither, and if you go back you'll see I predicted 60-70% of EQN and totally missed EQN/L. So clearly SOE is doing things differently with regards to this product.
I'm with you on being excited about a change in culture and direction that I saw. But I'm also taking what I see at face value, because essentially every speaker on that stage has, again, lied about a product I have purchased before. So I can be excited at the possibilities--but no one here should think these guys have anything other than ideas and a drive right now. Until they actually show some completed AI and zones? Their track record should indicate they are fluffing, or outright being deceitful.
And again, don't get me wrong, their ideas are exciting, the technology they showed was exciting, even how they SEEM to be making a game they want is exciting...However, their promises that X or Y is done and they are just "waiting" to show it off? heh.
No. That even felt like bullshit. (Deep down, you know it to bro. The dark side is strong in Smed.)