Marriage and the Power of Divorce

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

McCheese

SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
6,918
4,315
Dirk, did you and your wife get married right out of college? Did one of you have significantly more assets (cash, investments, property, etc) going into the marriage?

Granted, if marriage works properly, none of this matters. But if it goes to shit (especially if it does so within a few years of marriage) and you DID have significantly more wealth than your wife, keeping prior assets separate can be the difference between a relatively smooth divorce and a /wrists divorce.
How do you go about keeping your assets from before the marriage separate? Do you try to hide it somewhere in case of a future divorce, or do you simply tell your future wife that you want to keep all your pre-marriage stuff separate? I just can't imagine either scenario going over well with the vast majority of women. You said that you did this in your marriage, how did you go about keeping your pre-marriage assets separate from everything else?
 

Khane

Got something right about marriage
20,346
14,011
To be honest if a woman had a problem with me keeping my assets separate I'd walk away on the spot. That is a huge red flag.
 

ZyyzYzzy

RIP USA
<Banned>
25,295
48,789
I can see how it is easy to never tell someone about a Vanguard investment or stock holdings, especially if you get all reports via email
 

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,404
98,663
I can't speak for OH law, but if it is similar to TX law regarding marital property: I would hesitate to combine in money I had previous to getting married. That is probably what saved my ass in divorce.

Combining money made AFTER marriage is fine, that would all be considered community property anyway. But your assets prior to marriage would be yours to keep, and that is a lot easier to accomplish if you keep them separate. It also prevents the spiteful stealing of assets belonging you to if things go south.

A little caution doesn't hurt.
Ding ding ding, co mingling is terrible don't ever do it under any circumstances.
 

Haast

Lord Nagafen Raider
3,281
1,636
How do you go about keeping your assets from before the marriage separate? Do you try to hide it somewhere in case of a future divorce, or do you simply tell your future wife that you want to keep all your pre-marriage stuff separate? I just can't imagine either scenario going over well with the vast majority of women. You said that you did this in your marriage, how did you go about keeping your pre-marriage assets separate from everything else?
Hiding things from your spouse isn't a good idea in general, so I suggest telling them about the accounts. I made no attempt to hide my accounts, my ex-wife was well aware of them. If she insisted we combine all assets we had as soon as we said vows, I would be highly suspicious of motivations. Side note, my ex was presumptive and assumed they immediately became her property upon vows; I was well aware they didn't.

As far as how: once you are married, start joint account(s) and let new assets go there. Leave the previous assets as they were, separate and with only your name on them.

Of course, my marriage was an unmitigated train wreck, so take my advice with a grain of salt. It did not have to do with separated assets. Though she was very surprised she wasn't entitled to 50% of them after she blew things up.
 

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,404
98,663
Imo separate accounts for each person and a single joint account you both deposit into for bills and stuff.

And what the hell did qt420/10 mean? You talk like that irl?
 

Alex

Still a Music Elitist
14,670
7,488
Haast - Did you get to see your soon-to-be ex-wife's face when she found out she couldn't get those pre-marriage goodies?
 

Haast

Lord Nagafen Raider
3,281
1,636
Haast - Did you get to see your soon-to-be ex-wife's face when she found out she couldn't get those pre-marriage goodies?
Hell yeah I did. Bear in mind, we were married for about 6 months. Right as we started discussing how to split stuff up, she says "Well, I'm not sure I want my WHOLE 50% of everything...", and I started laughing. She didn't see what was funny. So I explained community property and showed her information that backed up my explanation. She was not laughing.

She hired a rather pricey lawyer to "protect her interests" (lol). Thankfully, there are no kids or other mitigating circumstances that might have made her sympathetic in court. The separate assets remained separate; the law is pretty clear there.
 

Onoes

Trakanon Raider
1,460
1,225
Wow, this is very interesting to me. My wife and I have always had 100% merged accounts/finances, and we don't even talk about who makes more, we consider both our incomes as "the income." I never worry that she's going to overspend on anything, nor do I ever feel the need to justify anything that I buy. If something is going to be a big purchase, we discuss it. Not because of the need for "permission" to spend the money, but because we have a certain amount each month that we consider to be usable for such things. If one of us needs to buy something expensive, the other may have to push off their own purchase a month. We simply communicate a lot about our finances.

Now you're telling me that because I make more, I need to put my wife on a stipend, and she needs permission to spend? I have so much to learn!
Ahhh, I think you're oversimplifying it. When I was married, I made 70% of the income, and my wife made 30%. Everything was deposited into one joint account. I would say, I spend maybe $40 a month on frivolous things, a couple games on steam, a book, shit like that. She didn't ever really make any large purchases herself, we never had the money too. Despite us having something like $1500 more our expenses per month, there was never more than a couple hundred dollars in the bank account, often it would be down to $60 or something. I would go through our accounts and see this shit (Ross $34, Starbucks $14, Walmart $82, Nail salon $75, Ross $56, Starbucks $11, The Garden Center $66, Jo'Annes $29) etc, etc, etc.

She would just spend $50-$100 on little frivolous shit. No matter how much I pointed it out, she just could not wrap her head around it. She was so dead set convinced that she never spends any money, because all she ever spent was on little things. It was incredibly frustrating, and led me to want to split the finances, not because I wanted to be my wife's boss and hold her on a stipend, but because she couldn't handle it. Even when it seemed to finally sink in, it didn't, because then she started making bigger purchases to REWARD herself for being so frugal the rest of the time. Basically, if the checking account balance had money in it, she just always assumed it was fine to spend that money, as long as it wasn't all spent in one lump sum.

It really sucks to get a good job, know you're bringing home $1000 a week or something, and have to wait for Tax return season to be able to buy a $300 monitor. I'm glad you don't have to deal with that, but implying that anyone who does must just be a chauvinist dick is a bit off the mark. I also feel like having the separation in finances can be a very healthy thing in a relationship. If your wife surprises you with cruise tickets or something for your birthday, while that might be cool and exciting, it might also make you go "Well fuck, I've never talked about going on a cruise, if I wanted to I would have set that up... but I guess you just spend "our" money on it... so it's ok.", presumably in your head, as you don't want to hurt your wife's feelings. Now if you have separate bank accounts, and she does the same thing, it's a much bigger deal. She had to save for that. She's sacrificing. You are going to appreciate that so much more. You lose that when you're sharing everything. Suddenly your a team, and everything is just expected because "We're on a team!".

I won't be combining my finances with another person again personally. Not because I don't want to spend my money on someone, if anything I'm WAY to generous as it is (which we've discussed before), but because I do like being able to decide exactly where and for what, my money goes towards.

As a side note, since getting divorced, taking on all financial obligations I have solo, keeping all of the debt as part of the divorce, and paying child support, I have SO MUCH more money. It's really crazy going from a point where I remember checking the bank before I went out to lunch, to just over a year later, when I can just go buy a brand new motorcycle or something if I wanted. That's the difference for me.
 

radditsu

Silver Knight of the Realm
4,676
826
Ahhh, I think you're oversimplifying it. When I was married, I made 70% of the income, and my wife made 30%. Everything was deposited into one joint account. I would say, I spend maybe $40 a month on frivolous things, a couple games on steam, a book, shit like that. She didn't ever really make any large purchases herself, we never had the money too. Despite us having something like $1500 more our expenses per month, there was never more than a couple hundred dollars in the bank account, often it would be down to $60 or something. I would go through our accounts and see this shit (Ross $34, Starbucks $14, Walmart $82, Nail salon $75, Ross $56, Starbucks $11, The Garden Center $66, Jo'Annes $29) etc, etc, etc.

She would just spend $50-$100 on little frivolous shit. No matter how much I pointed it out, she just could not wrap her head around it. She was so dead set convinced that she never spends any money, because all she ever spent was on little things. It was incredibly frustrating, and led me to want to split the finances, not because I wanted to be my wife's boss and hold her on a stipend, but because she couldn't handle it. Even when it seemed to finally sink in, it didn't, because then she started making bigger purchases to REWARD herself for being so frugal the rest of the time. Basically, if the checking account balance had money in it, she just always assumed it was fine to spend that money, as long as it wasn't all spent in one lump sum.

It really sucks to get a good job, know you're bringing home $1000 a week or something, and have to wait for Tax return season to be able to buy a $300 monitor. I'm glad you don't have to deal with that, but implying that anyone who does must just be a chauvinist dick is a bit off the mark. I also feel like having the separation in finances can be a very healthy thing in a relationship. If your wife surprises you with cruise tickets or something for your birthday, while that might be cool and exciting, it might also make you go "Well fuck, I've never talked about going on a cruise, if I wanted to I would have set that up... but I guess you just spend "our" money on it... so it's ok.", presumably in your head, as you don't want to hurt your wife's feelings. Now if you have separate bank accounts, and she does the same thing, it's a much bigger deal. She had to save for that. She's sacrificing. You are going to appreciate that so much more. You lose that when you're sharing everything. Suddenly your a team, and everything is just expected because "We're on a team!".

I won't be combining my finances with another person again personally. Not because I don't want to spend my money on someone, if anything I'm WAY to generous as it is (which we've discussed before), but because I do like being able to decide exactly where and for what, my money goes towards.

As a side note, since getting divorced, taking on all financial obligations I have solo, keeping all of the debt as part of the divorce, and paying child support, I have SO MUCH more money. It's really crazy going from a point where I remember checking the bank before I went out to lunch, to just over a year later, when I can just go buy a brand new motorcycle or something if I wanted. That's the difference for me.
Personal Budget Software - Finance Software for Windows & Mac


That bitch needs a budget.
 

Onoes

Trakanon Raider
1,460
1,225
Guess I'll follow Khane since the dating thread is dead.

So I basically befriended this girl at the gym, total qt420/10, and she wakes up at 5 am to workout with me. We go out to eat, she sits in my car with me for hours at a time just talking, etc. One night, I ask her to chill and don't get a response that night. Next morning I wake up to "omg I fell asleep sorry." I figured it was her way of telling me she's not interested, so I don't bring it up. Later on in the day I text her "you coming with me tomorrow morning?" No response. For a week. I figure she realizes I want more, she doesn't, her way of dealing with it is to avoid the situation. Kind of socially retarded, but whatever.

Fucking bitch texts me a week later "Hey :angryfaceemoji:" I'm like "the fuck does this bitch want?" Apparently she's all upset we haven't spoken in a week. I told her to fuck off since a phone works both ways. She claims she's been super sick, but wants to hang out. I go pick her up and she honestly looks like a god damn mess and clearly has an infection. I tell her to go to the doctor, sure as shit she has bronchitis, so I guess she's not a total liar. Anyway, fast forward 3 days later of talking/hanging out/lifting/eating/whatever we hook up.

What the fuck happened during that week? I'm guessing she ended things with the dude she was talking to before she met me. Or he ended things with her. I kind of feel like a tool, but whatever, pussy is pussy amirite?
Ohh almost forgot-

God damn if your post doesn't make you sound about as unlikable as someone can be. Girl apologies for missing your first text, then she misses another one and it must be because she is "Socially retarded". Then she texts you back and suddenly she's a fucking bitch? She tells you she was sick, you even verify she was sick, but there still must have been something else going on, because obviously she's a fucking liar. Also, pussy is pussy.

THEN, as if we weren't already going "What the fuck is this guys problem?" you regal us with the story of how a girl "tricked" you into thinking she was thinner than she was, and you are so disgusted that you can't even use her as a sexual object anymore. Sent that bitch packing through tears I assume. I'm sure your friends would have been high fiving you if they saw how alpha that shit was, right bro?

You're giving the rest of us a bad name with your dumb ass shit.

Also, fuck you for making me talk like a feminist.

Lastly, I hope you forehead kissed the girl who was just slightly outside of the perfect body type to put your fuckstick into.
 

Jysin

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
6,458
4,345
Go limp seeing her naked and send her out the door immediately = a-ok!

Forehead kiss = patronizing?

<notsureifserious>
 

Cad

scientia potentia est
<Bronze Donator>
25,439
49,087
I mean there's bound to be chicks that you just don't find arousing. Girls surely don't mind telling guys when they aren't attracted to them.
 

Itlan

Blackwing Lair Raider
4,994
744
I mean it was a shitty situation, but she brought it on herself with her god damn contorting.

And yeah, I don't think a kiss on the forehead would've helped the situation but that's just me.
 

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
46,404
98,663
You mean this skank who puts out at the drop of a hat doesnt have a good body? WHY I NEVER

You kick out the girls when you find out they have flapjack tits instead of perfect teardrops when they take off their bra?