There aren't too many options if an open relationship isn't workable and if she's unwilling to be faithful. She'll just keep cheating on you. So in reality you'll have the worst parts of an open relationship without any of the decent parts.
An awful lot of this depends on some real specific stuff about your situation though that you probably shouldn't talk to strangers on the internet about. You kinda need some actual facetime with a priest/therapist to work through the math of this. I mean someone you know, who knows you, whose judgement you are inclined to take seriously. Is she your wife, is she your nurse? And maybe I'm wrong, I hope I'm wrong, but I have some concerns that no divorce settlement would award primary custody to a handicapped father over an able bodied mother. No matter how much of a cheating slut she is. I mean christ, she could be a meth addict and they'd still give her the primary custody of the kids.
There's only so much that we can help, really. You deserve better. It genuinely sucks that she broke.
Again, even if I was okay with an open relationship, I really don't think she would be. I know it sounds weird with her lying and, while it sounds lame, emotionally cheating on me, but I just don't think she is built for that either. If she was going to actively have a sex life with someone else, I don't think she would want to keep me around also.
And yes I know, I am not reading all of this and going to run out and do what everyone suggests. This was more of a platform for me to vent, see how other people view it, and still make whatever decision I feel is best for me and my family.
As for going back to therapy, I think that is something that is still an option. Not to rehash the whole communication vs. acceptance argument again, but before all else she has to learn to communicate with me on how she is feeling, before shit gets to the point that she thinks seeking out another man is the best option. I think it will be important, whether she and I make it together or not, for her to go get her own counseling. I mean at the point that we actually saw the counselor she had already been talking with this guy and had feelings for him or whatever. At that point I still was not aware of that, and it never came up. She just sat there quietly, said maybe 5 sentences over a 60 minute session, and left it at that. Maybe that wasn't the best place to bring it up, but even the counselor was asking her "what else, what else?" trying to get her to open up more. I dunno, she has to learn to talk about her feelings to some extent.
And not to get too personal, but I will say say, ameraves, just because you can get her off like a champ that doesn't mean she doesn't feel like she is still missing something in the bedroom. Women need a good dickering at least every once in awhile.
This I fully understand. I am actually going to be getting surgery in a couple weeks to at least attempt to help this. It won't be the same since I still can't move around too much, but it is something. It very well may not work, and if that is the case oh well at least I tried. Hell, worst case scenario I can at least get a boner to play with now, even if I can't feel it. Here is a video (I will spoiler it since you probably don't want to watch it at work) that shows what I will be getting done. It is really quite fascinating!
Also, it's not the same as a lot of people on this thread where you go "Oh well, there are plenty of fish in the sea". Women that are up for dealing with Ameraves' situation are pretty few and far between I'm guessing so if you've got one it's worth trying to hold onto if you're not comfortable with the alternative which may very well be being alone.
I have thought a lot about what any sort of dating life for me would be like, and I fully accept that it would be pretty much non existant, and I think I am okay with that. I would simply go back to focusing on my family, put more effort into work, and probably have time to pick up some gaming again. I am okay with being alone really.
Ameraves, I know it hurts but people make mistakes. Take some time and think carefully about your decision, don't make it in anger.
And this is really what I am trying to do. I have always been quick tempered, but as I get older I can manage it much better. My reaction a few days ago was because I was beyond pissed, and it probably wasn't the right way to handle it. Above all else I have to do what is right for my kids and my family, not just for me. If I can't live with her and it gets to the point where I am just nasty to her all the time, that isn't something I want my kids to see and I would move on at that point.
Right or wrong, I think I was much more forgiving to her the first time because well, she is in a difficult position. My biggest gripe was that there was no discussion of this unhappiness, just finding out FuckFace was in the picture. That is the part that wounded me more than anything. The second time she got caught lying is when I found it totally unacceptable. Not that the first time was okay either, but I at least sorta get it.
All that being said, I think people give up on marriage too easily. Marriage isn't easy and you have to work through the tough times, or at least give it a very concerted effort. Of course there is a point of no return, and maybe my marriage is already there and I just don't know it yet. I am going to once again push her towards counseling for herself, and then for us once she gets some of her shit sorted out. And if it doesn't work out, and it turns out she is talking to him again, then I can't point to anyone but myself for allowing it to happen again. Who knows though. I am still going through lots of ups and downs with this, and find myself getting angry when I think about it. It is always quite possible I simply walk (hah, roll!) away from this because I can't forgive her for it. I am just going to take some time and attempt to think it through, then make a long term plan.